The Role of Energy Consumption and Economic Growth on Human Development in Emerging (E-7) Countries: Fresh Evidence from Second-Generation Panel Data Analyses
Oktay Kizilkaya
Malatya Turgut Özal University (Turkey)
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3412-5616
Oktay Kizilkaya
okizilkaya@ahievran.edu.trKırşehir Ahi Evran University (Turkey)
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7165-6088
Gökhan Akar
Karamanoglu Mehmetbey University (Turkey)
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8401-4052
Faruk Mike
Osmaniye Korkut Ata University (Turkey)
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9194-1679
Abstract
This study aims to examine the impacts of energy consumption and economic growth on the human development index of seven emerging countries (E-7) with high economic performance for yearly observations from 1992 to 2021. The analyses were carried out with second-generation panel data analyses: (i) Panel cointegration test with structural breaks proposed by Westerlund (2006), (ii) augmented mean group estimator recommended by Eberhardt and Bond (2009), and (iii) Dumitrescu and Hurlin (2012) panel causality test. The empirical model also included trade openness and urbanization parameters as control variables. The panel cointegration test outcomes reveal the presence of a long-run relation among the human development index and energy consumption, economic growth, urbanization, and trade openness for all countries. Augmented mean group test outcomes signify that energy consumption, economic growth, and trade openness have positive and statistically significant impacts on the human development index, whereas urbanization does not have any statistically significant impact in the long-run. Finally, panel causality test results signify that there is a bidirectional relation between the human development index and energy consumption, economic growth, and trade openness and also a unidirectional relation from urbanization to the human development index in E-7 countries. All these findings indicate that the main macroeconomic indicators have an important role on the human development index in E-7 countries. In this context, these countries should implement a more effective and innovative economic policy for Sustainable development goals.
Keywords:
Human development index, economic growth, energy consumption, E-7 countries, panel data estimationsReferences
ACHEAMPONG A. O., ERDIAW-KWASIE M. O., ABUNYEWAH M., 2021, Does energy accessibility improve human development? Evidence from energy-poor regions, Energy Economics, 96: 105165.
Google Scholar
ADEKOYA O. B., OLABODE J. K., RAFI S. K., 2021, Renewable energy consumption, carbon emissions and human development: Empirical comparison of the trajectories of world regions, Renewable Energy, 179: 1836-1848.
Google Scholar
AFGAN N. H., AL GOBAISI D., CARVALHO M. G., CUMO M., 1998, Sustainable energy development, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2(3): 235-286.
Google Scholar
AKAR G., SARITAS T. KIZILKAYA O., 2021, The Impact of Human Development on Economic Growth: An Applica-tion on Transition Economies, Business and Economics Research Journal, 12(2): 307-318.
Google Scholar
ALSTONE P., GERSHENSON D., KAMMEN D. M., 2015, Decentralized energy systems for clean electricity access, Nature climate change, 5(4): 305-314.
Google Scholar
AMER H., 2020, The impact of renewable energy consumption on the human development index in selected countries: panel analysis (1990–2015), Int J Econ Energy Environ, 5(4): 47.
Google Scholar
ANISUJJAMAN M., 2015, Urbanisation and human development: a study of West Bengal, International Journal of Humanities and Social Science Invention, 4(7): 1-8.
Google Scholar
ARISMAN A., 2018, Determinant of human development index in ASEAN countries, Signifikan, 7(1): 113-122.
Google Scholar
AZAM A., RAFIQ M., SHAFIQUE M., YUAN J., SALEM S., 2021, Human development index, ICT, and renewable energy-growth nexus for sustainable development: a novel PVAR analysis, Frontiers in Energy Research, 9: 760758.
Google Scholar
BAI J., PERRON P., 2003, Computation and analysis of multiple structural change models, Journal of Applied Economet-rics, 18(1): 1-22.
Google Scholar
BANDAY U. J., KOCOGLU M., 2022, Modelling simultaneous relationships between human development, energy, and environment: Fresh evidence from panel quantile regression, Journal of the Knowledge Economy, 14: 1559–1581.
Google Scholar
BEHAILU A., 2023, The Impact of Trade Openness and Foreign Direct Investment on Human Development in Sub-Saharan African Countries: Evidence from Panel Data, The Ethiopian Journal of Business and Economics, 13(1): 1-33.
Google Scholar
BEN MBAREK M., BOUKARRAA B., SAIDI K., 2016, Role of energy consumption and economic growth in the spread of greenhouse emissions: empirical evidence from Spain, Environmental earth sciences, 75(16): 1161.
Google Scholar
BERTINELLI L., BLACK D., 2004, Urbanization and growth, Journal of Urban Economics, 56(1): 80-96.
Google Scholar
BERRYMAN T., SAUVE L., 2016, Ruling relationships in sustainable development and education for sustainable devel-opment, The Journal of Environmental Education, 47(2): 104-117.
Google Scholar
BHATTACHARYA B., 1998, Urbanisation and human development in West Bengal: A district level study and compari-son with inter-state variation, Economic and Political Weekly, 33(47-48): 3027-3032.
Google Scholar
BIGGERI M., Mauro V., 2018, Towards a more ‘sustainable’ human development index: Integrating the environment and freedom, Ecological Indicators, 91: 220-231.
Google Scholar
BILDIRICI M. E., GOKMENOGLU S. M., 2017, Environmental pollution, hydropower energy consumption and eco-nomic growth: Evidence from G7 countries, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 75: 68-85.
Google Scholar
BOOZER M., RANIS G., STEWART F., SURI T., 2003, Paths to success: the relationship between human development and economic growth, SSRN 487469.
Google Scholar
BRAVO G., 2014, The Human Sustainable Development Index: New calculations and a first critical analysis, Ecological Indicators, 37: 145-150.
Google Scholar
BREITUNG J., 2005, A parametric approach to the estimation of cointegration vectors in panel data, Econometric Reviews, 24(2): 151-173.
Google Scholar
BREUSCH T. S., PAGAN A. R., 1980, The Lagrange Multiplier Test and Its Applications to Model Specification Tests in Econometrics, Review of Economic Studies, 47(1): 239-53.
Google Scholar
BROOK B. W., ALONSO A., MENELEY D. A., MISAK J., BLEES T., VAN ERP J. B., 2014, Why nuclear energy is sustainable and has to be part of the energy mix, Sustainable Materials and Technologies, 1: 8-16.
Google Scholar
CARBON BRIEF, 2021, Analysis: Which countries are historically responsible for climate change?, https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-which-countries-are-historically-responsible-for-climate-change/.
Google Scholar
CASILLAS C. E., KAMMEN D. M., 2010, The energy-poverty-climate nexus, Science, 330(6008): 1181-1182.
Google Scholar
CHANKRAJANG T., MUTTARAK R., 2017, Green returns to education: Does schooling contribute to pro-environmental behaviours? Evidence from Thailand, Ecological Economics, 131: 434-448.
Google Scholar
CHOVANCOVA J., VAVREK R., 2019, Decoupling analysis of energy consumption and economic growth of V4 coun-tries, Problemy Ekorozwoju/ Problems of Sustainable Development, 14(1): 159-165.
Google Scholar
CONCEICAO P., 2019, Human development and the SDGs, Human Development Report. https://hdr.undp.org/content/human-development-and-sdgs.
Google Scholar
CONSTANTINI V., MONNI S., 2005, Sustainable human development for European countries, Journal of Human Development, 6(3): 329-351.
Google Scholar
COSTANTINI V., MONNI S., 2008, Sustainability and human development, Economia politica, 25(1): 11-32.
Google Scholar
DANENSHMAND NARUEE M., PAHLAVANI M., ESFANDIARINI M., 2022, The Impact of Urbanization on Human Development Index in the Provinces of Iran: Quantile Regression Method, Journal of Iranian Economic Is-sues, 9(1): 163-184.
Google Scholar
DE NEVE J. E., SACHS J. D., 2020, Sustainable development and human well-being, World Happiness Report: 112-127.
Google Scholar
DUMITRESCU E. I., HURLIN C., 2012, Testing for Granger non-causality in heterogeneous panels, Economic model-ling, 29(4): 1450-1460.
Google Scholar
DUMOR K., LI Y., AMOUZOU E. K., AMPAW E. M., KURSAH M. B., AKAKPO K., 2022, Modeling the dynamic nexus among CO2 emissions, fossil energy usage, and human development in East Africa: new insight from the novel DARDL simulation embeddedness, Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 29(37): 56265-56280.
Google Scholar
EBERHARDT M., BOND S., 2009, Cross-section Dependence in Nonstationary Panel Models: A Novel Estimator, MPRA (Munich Personal RePEc Archive), Paper No: 17692, https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/17692.
Google Scholar
ELLIOT D., 2000, Renewable energy and sustainable futures, Futures, 32(3-4): 261-274.
Google Scholar
ESTOQUE R. C., MURAYAMA Y., 2014, Social–ecological status index: A preliminary study of its structural composi-tion and application, Ecological Indicators, 43: 183-194.
Google Scholar
FANKEM G., OUMAROU M., 2020, Trade Openness and Economic Growth in Sub-Saharan Africa: Evidence from New Trade Openness Indicator, Economics Bulletin, 40(4): 2920-2931.
Google Scholar
FATIMA N., LI, Y., AHMAD M., JABEEN G., LI X, 2019, Analyzing long-term empirical interactions between renew-able energy generation, energy use, human capital, and economic performance in Pakistan, Energy, Sustainability and Soci-ety, 9(1): 1-14.
Google Scholar
GALLOPIN G. C., 2003, A systems approach to sustainability and sustainable development, UN Publ., Santiago, Chile.
Google Scholar
GOHLKE J. M., THOMAS R., WOODWARD A., CAMPBELL-LENDRUM D., PRRUSS-ÜSTUN A., HALES S., PORTIER C. J., 2011, Estimating the global public health implications of electricity and coal consumption, Environmental health perspectives, 119(6): 821-826.
Google Scholar
GODFREY R., JULIEN M., 2005, Urbanisation and health, Clinical Medicine, 5(2): 137-141.
Google Scholar
GOZGOR G., LAU C. K. M., LU Z., 2018, Energy consumption and economic growth: New evidence from the OECD countries, Energy, 153: 27-34.
Google Scholar
GRIFFIN K., McKINLEY T., GRIFFIN K., McKINLEY T., 1994, Human development and sustainable develop-ment, Implementing a Human Development Strategy: 96-102, https://books.google.pl/books?hl=pl&lr=&id=fkauCwAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR10&dq=McKINLEY+T.,+1994,+Human+development+and+sustainable+development,+Implementing+a+Human+Development+Strategy&ots=0pZur2d0Mi&sig=VnRw5cO4oGzRebsfV4DPVTl89Es&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false.
Google Scholar
HAN J., XIE D., AHMED Z., KHAN S. U., KIRIKKLELI D., 2023, Green technologies, government stability, and green energy transition in a globalized world: evidence from E-7 nations, Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 30: 92255–92266.
Google Scholar
HAMDI H., HAKIMI A., 2022, Trade openness, foreign direct investment, and human development: a panel cointegration analysis for MENA countries, The International Trade Journal, 36(3): 219-238.
Google Scholar
HARRIS J. M., 2003, Sustainability and sustainable development, International Society for Ecological Economics, 1(1): 1-12.
Google Scholar
HASHEMIZADEH A., BUI Q., ZAIDI S. A. H., 2022, A blend of renewable and nonrenewable energy consumption in G-7 countries: The role of disaggregate energy in human development, Energy, 241: 122520.
Google Scholar
HICKEL J., 2020, The sustainable development index: Measuring the ecological efficiency of human development in the Anthropocene, Ecological Economics, 167: 106331.
Google Scholar
HONG T., YU N., MAO Z., ZHANG S., 2021, Government-driven urbanisation and its impact on regional economic growth in China, Cities, 117: 103299.
Google Scholar
HUANG G., JIANG Y., 2017, Urbanization and socioeconomic development in inner Mongolia in 2000 and 2010: a GIS analysis, Sustainability, 9(2): 235.
Google Scholar
HUSKIĆ M., SATROVIĆ E., 2020, Human development-renewable energy-growth nexus in the top 10 energy glut-tons, Uprava, 11(1): 25-42.
Google Scholar
HUSSAIN M., MIR G. M., USMAN M., YE C., MANSOOR S., 2022, Analysing the role of environment-related tech-nologies and carbon emissions in emerging economies: a step towards sustainable development, Environmental Technolo-gy, 43(3): 367-375.
Google Scholar
HUSSEIN M. A., LEAL FILHO W., 2012, Analysis of energy as a precondition for improvement of living conditions and poverty reduction in sub-Saharan Africa, Scientific Research and Essays, 7(30): 2656-2666.
Google Scholar
IBRAHIM R. L., AJIDE K. B., OMOKANMI O. J., 2021, Non-renewable energy consumption and quality of life: Evi-dence from Sub-Saharan African economies, Resources Policy, 73: 102176.
Google Scholar
IEA, 2020, Key World Energy Statistics, World Energy Outlook, https://www.iea.org/reports/world-energy-outlook-2020.
Google Scholar
IEA, 2022, World Energy Outlook, https://www.iea.org/reports/world-energy-outlook-2022.
Google Scholar
IEA, 2023, World Energy Outlook, https://www.iea.org/reports/world-energy-outlook-2023.
Google Scholar
INGLESI-LOTZ R., 2016, The impact of renewable energy consumption to economic growth: A panel data application, Energy economics, 53: 58-63.
Google Scholar
JEPSON Jr E. J., 2004, Human nature and sustainable development: A strategic challenge for planners, Journal of Plan-ning Literature, 19(1): 3-15.
Google Scholar
JIN H., QIAN X., CHIN T., ZHANG H., 2020, A global assessment of sustainable development based on modification of the human development index via the entropy method, Sustainability, 12(8): 3251.
Google Scholar
KABADYAI B., 2013, Human development and trade openness: A case study on developing countries, Advances in Management and Applied Economics, 3(3): 193.
Google Scholar
KAHIA M., AISSA M. S. B., CHARFEDDINE L. 2016, Impact of renewable and non-renewable energy consumption on economic growth: New evidence from the MENA Net Oil Exporting Countries (NOECs), Energy, 116: 102-115.
Google Scholar
KANAGAWA M., NAKATA T., 2008, Assessment of access to electricity and the socio-economic impacts in rural areas of developing countries, Energy policy, 36(6): 2016-2029.
Google Scholar
KAREKEZI S., McDADE S., BOARDMAN B., KIMANI J., LUSTIG N., 2012, Global Energy Assessment (GEA): energy, poverty, and development, https://previous.iiasa.ac.at/web/home/research/Flagship-Projects/Global-Energy-Assessment/GEA_Chapter2_development_lowres.pdf.
Google Scholar
KHAN N. H., JU Y., HASSAN S. T., 2019, Investigating the determinants of human development index in Pakistan: an empirical analysis, Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 26: 19294-19304.
Google Scholar
KOCAK E., ŞARKGUNESI A., 2017, The renewable energy and economic growth nexus in Black Sea and Balkan coun-tries, Energy policy, 100: 51-57.
Google Scholar
KONGKUAH M., YAO H., YILANCI V., 2022, The relationship between energy consumption, economic growth, and CO2 emissions in China: The role of urbanisation and international trade, Environment, Development and Sustainability, 24(4): 4684-4708.
Google Scholar
KUMAR S., 2017, Trade and Human Development: Case of ASEAN, Pacific Business Review International, 12: 48-57.
Google Scholar
LANDORF H., DOSCHER S., ROCCO T., 2008, Education for sustainable human development: Towards a defini-tion, Theory and Research in Education, 6(2): 221-236.
Google Scholar
LI X., WANG C., ZHANG G., XIAO L., DIXON J., 2012, Urbanisation and human health in China: spatial features and a systemic perspective, Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 19: 1375-1384.
Google Scholar
MAITI M., 2017, Urbanisation and inequalities in China and India. Overview and comparative study, Theoretical & Ap-plied Economics, 4(613): 121-136.
Google Scholar
MARINEZ D. M., EBENHACK B. W., 2008, Understanding the role of energy consumption in human development through the use of saturation phenomena, Energy Policy, 36(4): 1430-1435.
Google Scholar
MAZUR A., 2011, Does increasing energy or electricity consumption improve quality of life in industrial nations?, Energy Policy, 39(5): 2568-2572.
Google Scholar
MBABAZI G., 2017, The Impact of Trade on Human Development in Sub-Saharan Africa (SSA), Master Thesis in Eco-nomics, Jönköping University International Business School, Sweden.
Google Scholar
MOORE M., GOULD P., KEARY B. S., 2003, Global urbanization and impact on health, International journal of hy-giene and environmental health, 206(4-5): 269-278.
Google Scholar
MORAN D. D., WACKERNAGEL M., KITZES J. A., GOLDFINGER S. H., BOUTAUD A., 2008, Measuring sus-tainable development – Nation by nation, Ecological economics, 64(3): 470-474.
Google Scholar
MOSTEANU D., MIHAILA-LICA G., HALMAGHI E. E., MOSTEANU R., 2014, The sustainable development-human development, Land Forces Academy Review, 19(1): 106.
Google Scholar
MOUROGOV V. M., 2000, Role of nuclear energy for sustainable development, Progress in Nuclear Energy, 37(1-4): 19-24.
Google Scholar
MURILLO-ALVARADO P. E., PONCE-ORTEGA J. M., 2022, An optimization approach to increase the human devel-opment index through a biogas supply chain in a developing region, Renewable Energy, 190: 347-357.
Google Scholar
MUSTAFA G., RIZOV M., KERNOHAN D., 2017, Growth, human development, and trade: The Asian experi-ence, Economic Modelling, 61: 93-101.
Google Scholar
NATHANIEL S. P., 2021, Natural resources, urbanisation, economic growth and the ecological footprint in South Africa: The moderating role of human capital, Quaestiones Geographicae, 40(2): 63-76.
Google Scholar
NAZEER M., TABASSUM U., ALAM S., 2016, Environmental pollution and sustainable development in developing countries, The Pakistan Development Review: 589-604.
Google Scholar
NGUEA S. M., 2023, Improving human development through urbanization, demographic dividend and biomass energy consumption, Sustainable Development, 31(4): 2517-2535.
Google Scholar
NIU S., JIA Y., WANG W., HE R., HU L., LIU Y., 2013, Electricity consumption and human development level: A comparative analysis based on panel data for 50 countries, International Journal of Electrical Power & Energy Sys-tems, 53: 338-347.
Google Scholar
NIPO D. T., LILY J., IDRIS S., PINJAMAN S., BUJANG I., 2021, Globalisation, Urbanisation and Human Develop-ment: Evidence from Lower-Middle Income Economies, International Journal of Academic Research in Economics and Managment and Sciences, 10(3): 154–167.
Google Scholar
NJIRU C. W., LETEMA S. C., 2018, Energy poverty and its implication on standard of living in Kirinyaga, Ken-ya, Journal of Energy, 2018(9): 1-12.
Google Scholar
NJOH A. J., 2003, Urbanization and development in sub-Saharan Africa, Cities, 20(3): 167-174.
Google Scholar
OMRI A., BELAID F., 2021, Does renewable energy modulate the negative effect of environmental issues on the socio-economic welfare? Journal of Environmental Management, 278: 111483.
Google Scholar
OPOKU E. E. O., DOGAH K. E., ALUKO O. A., 2022, The contribution of human development towards environmental sustainability, Energy Economics, 106: 105782.
Google Scholar
OUDEDRAOGO N. S., 2013, Energy consumption and human development: Evidence from a panel cointegration and error correction model, Energy, 63: 28-41.
Google Scholar
PASTEN C., SANTAMARINA J. C., 2012, Energy and quality of life. Energy Policy, 49: 468-476.
Google Scholar
PESARAN M. H., 2004, General Diagnostic Tests for Cross Section Dependence in Panels, Cambridge Working Papers in Economics No. 435.
Google Scholar
PESARAN M. H., 2006, Estimation and Inference in Large Heterogeneous Panels with a Multifactor Error Structure, Econometrica, 74(4): 967-1012.
Google Scholar
PESARAN M. H., 2007, A simple panel unit root test in the presence of cross‐section dependence, Journal of applied econometrics, 22(2): 265-312.
Google Scholar
PESARAN M. H., ULLAH A., YAMAGATA T., 2008, A Bias-Adjusted LM Test of Error Cross-Section Independ-ence, Econometrics Journal, 11(1): 105-127.
Google Scholar
PESARAN M.H., YAMAGATA T., 2008,, Testing Slope Homogeneity in Large Panels, Journal of Econometrics, 142(1): 50-93.
Google Scholar
PHAM A., LI C., BUI Q., 2024, Assessing the heterogeneous impacts of energy consumption on human ,development of G7 by employing advanced quantile panel data estimation, Gondwana Research, 127: 211-225.
Google Scholar
PIRLOGEA C., 2012, The human development relies on energy. Panel data evidence, Procedia economics and Finance, 3: 496-501.
Google Scholar
RANIS G., STEWART F., 2005, Dynamic links between the economy and human development, Department for Economic and Social Affairs Working Paper No. 8, United Nations, New York.
Google Scholar
RAY S., GHOSH B., BARDHAN S., BHATTACHARYYA B., 2016, Studies on the impact of energy quality on hu-man development index, Renewable energy, 92: 117-126.
Google Scholar
ROY H., GUPTA A., JAYARAJ R., 2015, Energy consumption and human development: global perspective, Economics and policy of Energy and the Environment, Franco Angeli Editore 2015(1): 111-131.
Google Scholar
SADIQ M., WEN F., BASHIR M. F., AMIN A., 2022a, Does nuclear energy consumption contribute to human devel-opment? Modeling the effects of public debt and trade globalization in an OECD heterogeneous panel, Journal of Cleaner Production, 375: 133965.
Google Scholar
SADIQ M., SHINWARI R., USMAN M., OZTURK I., MAGHYEREH A. I., 2022b, Linking nuclear energy, human development and carbon emission in BRICS region: Do external debt and financial globalization protect the environ-ment?, Nuclear Engineering and Technology, 54(9): 3299-3309.
Google Scholar
SAQIB N., USMAN M., RADULESCU M., SINISI C. I., SECARA C. G., TOLEA C., 2022, Revisiting EKC hypothe-sis in context of renewable energy, human development and moderating role of technological innovations in E-7 coun-tries, Front Environ Sci, 10(2509): 10-3389.
Google Scholar
SASMAZ M. U., SAKAR E., YAYLA Y. E., AKKUCUK U., 2020, The relationship between renewable energy and human development in OECD countries: A panel data analysis, Sustainability, 12(18): 7450.
Google Scholar
SATROVIC E., 2018, The human development relies on renewable energy: evidence from Turkey, Proceedings of the 3rd International Energy & Engineering, Book of Proceedings, Gaziantep, Turkey: 19-27.
Google Scholar
SMITH S., 2016, Determinants of human development index: A cross-country empirical analysis, SSRG Int. J. Econ. Manag. Stud., 3: 40-43.
Google Scholar
SOFILDA E., HERMIYANTI P., HAMZAH M., 2015, Determinant variable analysis of human development index in Indonesia (Case for high and low index at period 2004-2013), OIDA International Journal of Sustainable Develop-ment, 8(09): 11-28.
Google Scholar
SOLARIN S. A., SHAHBAZ M., 2013, Trivariate causality between economic growth, urbanisation and electricity con-sumption in Angola: Cointegration and causality analysis, Energy policy, 60: 876-884.
Google Scholar
STERN D. I., 2011, The role of energy in economic growth, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences, 1219(1): 26-51.
Google Scholar
STOENOIU C. E., 2018, Pattern of Energy Productivity and Gross Domestic Product Among European Countries, Prob-lemy Ekorozwoju/ Problems of Sustainable Development, 13(2): 113-123.
Google Scholar
SURI T., BOOZER M. A., RANIS G., STEWART F., 2011, Paths to success: The relationship between human develop-ment and economic growth, World Development, 39(4): 506-522.
Google Scholar
SWAMY P.A.V.B., 1970, Efficient Inference in a Random Coefficient Regression Model, Econometrica, 38(2): 311-323.
Google Scholar
TAHIR M., KHAN I., 2014, Trade openness and economic growth in the Asian region, Journal of Chinese Economic and Foreign Trade Studies, 7(3): 136-152.
Google Scholar
TAMANG P., 2013, Urbanisation and economic growth: Investigating causality, Econometrics, 1(3): 41-47.
Google Scholar
TONG T., ORTIZ J., XU C., LI F., 2020, Economic growth, energy consumption, and carbon dioxide emissions in the E7 countries: a bootstrap ARDL bound test, Energy, Sustainability and Society, 10(1): 1-17.
Google Scholar
TRIPATHI S., 2021, How does urbanization affect the human development index? A cross-country analysis, Asia-Pacific Journal of Regional Science, 5(3): 1053-1080.
Google Scholar
TSOKALIDA E. E., YANG J., 2019, Examining Trade by Destination, Innovation and Human Development in FO-CAC, Open Journal of Business and Management, 7(03): 1225.
Google Scholar
UCHE E., 2022, Strategic pathways to combating remittance-induced carbon emissions; the imperatives of renewable energy, structural transformations, urbanization and human development, Energy Sources, Part B: Economics, Planning, and Policy, 17(1): 2141375.
Google Scholar
UNDP, 1990, Human Development Report, Oxford University Press, New York.
Google Scholar
UNDP, 2022, Human Development Index (HDI), https://hdr.undp.org/data-center/human-development-index#/indicies/HDI (16.11.2023).
Google Scholar
UN, 2023, Sustainable Development Goals, https://sdgs.un.org/goals (16.11.2023).
Google Scholar
VAN TRAN N., VAN TRAN Q., DO L. T. T., DINH L. H., DO H. T. T., 2019, Trade off between environment, energy consumption and human development: Do levels of economic development matter?, Energy, 173: 483-493.
Google Scholar
WANG Z., ZHANG B., WANG B., 2018, Renewable energy consumption, economic growth and human development index in Pakistan: evidence form simultaneous equation model, Journal of cleaner production, 184: 1081-1090.
Google Scholar
WANG Z., RASOOL Y., AASGHAR M. M., WANG B., 2019, Dynamic linkages among CO2 emissions, human devel-opment, financial development, and globalization: empirical evidence based on PMG long-run panel estima-tion, Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 26: 36248-36263.
Google Scholar
WANG Z., BUI Q., ZHANG B., 2020, The relationship between biomass energy consumption and human development: Empirical evidence from BRICS countries, Energy, 194: 116906.
Google Scholar
WANG Z., BUI Q., ZHANG B., NAWARATHNA C. L. K., MOMBEUIL C., 2021, The nexus between renewable energy consumption and human development in BRICS countries: The moderating role of public debt, Renewable Ener-gy, 165: 381-390.
Google Scholar
WARR B. S., AYRES R. U., 2010, Evidence of causality between the quantity and quality of energy consumption and economic growth, Energy, 35(4): 1688-1693.
Google Scholar
WESTERLUND J., 2006, Testing for panel cointegration with multiple structural breaks, Oxford Bulletin of Economics and Statistics, 68(1): 101-132.
Google Scholar
Authors
Oktay Kizilkayaokizilkaya@ahievran.edu.tr
Kırşehir Ahi Evran University Turkey
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-7165-6088
Statistics
Abstract views: 271PDF downloads: 143