CONSERVATION-RESTORATION AND CONSERVATION SCIENCE - THE CHALLENGE OF TRANSDISCIPLINARITY
Article Sidebar
Open full text
Issue No. 8 (2019)
-
„OPEN FOR CONSERVATION”: LIVE EXPERIENCES
Cobau Andreina Costanzi79-88
-
THE ETHICAL PROBLEMS OF ARCHITECTURAL RECONSTRUCTION – HUNGARIAN CASE STUDIES
Ádám Arnóth1-8
-
ON PRINCIPLES AND OBJECTIVITY
Wolfgang Baatz9-14
-
REFLECTION ON CONSERVATION-RESTORATION PRACTICE TODAY. A EUROPEAN PERSPECTIVE
Stefan Belishki, Susan Corr15-28
-
AFTER BRANDI – UMBERTO BALDINI AND THE MODERN THEORY OF CONSERVATION-RESTORATION IN ITALY
Giorgio Bonsanti29-36
-
PROFESSIONAL INTERDISCIPLINARY POSITION AND ROLE OF ACADEMIC CONSERVATOR-RESTORERS IN THEORY AND PRACTICE Methodical symbiosis and transdisciplinary cooperation using the example of the rebuilding and conservation of two Ottoman palaces in Istanbul
Jörg Breitenfeldt37-42
-
INTEGRATION OF BRANDI’S THEORY IN THE CONTEXT OF EASTERN RELIGIONS AND CULTURES
Francesca Capanna43-52
-
RETHINKING MAIURI: ENHANCEMENT OF STUCCO FINDINGS FROM THE HERCULANEUM ARCHAEOLOGICAL PARKq
Filippo Edoardo Capasso, Francesca Castiello, Simona Dichiara, Manuel Giandomenico, Natalie Iacopino, Erika Maddalena, Camilla Mauri, Sokol Muca, Mariagiulia Roscigno, Sofia Schiattone53-64
-
THE METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH IN THE MANAGEMENT OF CONSERVATION DATA FOR STUCCO ARTIFACTS
Filippo Edoardo Capasso, Francesca Castiello, Simona Dichiara, Manuel Giandomenico, Natalie Iacopino, Erika Maddalena, Camilla Mauri, Sokol Muca, Mariagiulia Roscigno, Sofia Schiattone65-72
-
THE STUCCO DECORATION OF THE MONUMENTAL ARCH ON THE DECUMANUS MAXIMUS AT HERCULANEUM
Marina Caso73-78
-
“CONSERVATION VERSUS RECONSTRUCTION.” DO WE NEED OTHER OR NEW CRITERIA FOR CONSERVING ARCHITECTURAL SURFACES OF THE 20THCENTURY?
Thomas Danzl89-102
-
THE CONSERVATION-RESTORATION OF ARCHITECTURAL STATUARY IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE ETHICAL REQUIREMENTS FOR SCULPTURE AND ARCHITECTURE
Camille De Clercq, Judy De Roy103-112
-
LUCIO FONTANA AND ARCHITECTURE
Barbara Ferriani113-122
-
AWARENESS OF MATERIALITY IN TIME AND CONDITION. THOUGHTS ON THE RELATION BETWEEN ART HISTORY AND CONSERVATION
Andreas Huth, Katharine Stahlbuhk123-138
-
„BEFORE WE UNDERSTAND WHAT WE ARE DOING, WE NEED TO KNOW HOW WE THINK”
Dörthe Jakobs139-150
-
THE TEMPLE OF EPICURIOUS APOLLO AT BASSAE: PRESERVE THE STONE OR UNCOVER ITS TRUE NATURE?
Eva Kapadoukaki, Michail Soumas151-158
-
GIOTTO’S STIGMATIZATION OF SAINT FRANCIS: AN APPROACH FOR THE RECONSTRUCTION OF THE IMAGE
Maria Rosa Lanfranchi159-174
-
ETHICS AND BASIC PRINCIPLES OF RESTORING HISTORICAL STONE MONUMENTS
Jadwiga W. Łukaszewicz175-184
-
PUBLIC ENGAGEMENT TOWARDS SUSTAINABLE HERITAGE PRESERVATION
Helia Marcal185-210
-
VIRTUAL CONSERVATION-RESTORATION VS. ACTUAL CONSERVATION-RESTORATION IN THE CONSERVATION OF FRAGMENTARY ARTEFACTS: THE CASE STUDY FRESCOES FROM SYBARIS - COPIA (ITALY)
Sokol Muca211-222
-
CONSERVATION-RESTORATION AND CONSERVATION SCIENCE - THE CHALLENGE OF TRANSDISCIPLINARITY
Mechthild Noll-Minor223-238
-
QUALITY PARAMETERS IN CONSERVATION-RESTORATION CHOICES – THE CASE OF THE TOWER OF THE WINDS IN ATHENS
Maria Papadopoulou, Andromache Gazi239-254
-
ETHICAL CHALLENGES IN THE CONSERVATION OF THE WALL PAINTINGS OF CHAPEL 11 AT THE SACRO MONTE DI VARALLO
Francesca Piqué, Giacinta Jean255-268
-
UNITÉ DE DOCTRINE – CONTINGENCY OF PRACTICE? TOWARDS A RE-READING OF TWENTIETH CENTURY PRINCIPLES OF BUILDING HERITAGE CONSERVATION
Andreas Putz269-280
-
THE VOICE OF CONSERVATION-RESTORATION ON MULTI-DISCIPLINARY RESTORATION PROJECTS
Tanja Røskar281-290
-
CONSERVATION ETHICS TODAY: ARE OUR CONSERVATION-RESTORATION THEORIES AND PRACTICE READY FOR THE TWENTY-FIRST CENTURY? INTRODUCTORY NOTES TO SOME CENTRAL ISSUES
Ursula Schädler-Saub291-300
-
DEALING WITH AUTHENTICITY IN THE CONSERVATION AND RESTORATION OF WALL PAINTINGS AND ARCHITECTURAL SURFACES
Ursula Schädler-Saub301-324
-
THE CONSERVATOR’S RESPONSIBILITY FOR THE DETERIORATION OF MONUMENTS
Bogusław Szmygin325-333
Main Article Content
DOI
Authors
Abstract
Transdisciplinarity has shaped the development of both conservation science and conservation-restoration. The history of conservation science demands the commitment of all involved specialists to follow a common vision in the field. The present article highlights some key lessons to assist in closing the gap between the promotion of high-level research projects and the development and assessment of proficient professional practice in conservation science and conservation-restoration. The necessary framework conditions should also be brought to the attention of responsible politicians.
Reflecting on conservation theory and practice “at the turn of the millennium” I propose to take a closer look at interdisciplinary work devoted to maintenance of Cultural Heritage since the beginning of the 20th century.
Keywords:
References
BLDAM (1998): Erforschung und Erhaltung historischer Putze und Mörtel im Hinblick auf Umweltschäden. Arbeitshefte des Brandenburgisches Landesdenkmalamtes und Archäologischen Landesmuseums Nr. 9. Worms: Wernersche Verlagsgesellschaft
BLDAM (2009). Umweltbedingte Pigmentveränderungen an mittelalterlichen Wandmalereien. Arbeitshefte des Brandenburgisches Landesdenkmalamtes und Archäologischen Landesmuseums Nr. 24. Worms: Wernersche Verlagsgesellschaft
BLDAM (2010). Mittelalterliche Wandmalerei in Brandenburg, Band 1: Der Südosten – die Brandenburgische Lausitz. Forschungen und Beiträge des Brandenburgisches Landesdenkmalamtes und Archäologischen Landesmuseums. Worms: Wernersche Verlagsgesellschaft
BLDAM (2019). Mittelalterliche Wandmalerei in Brandenburg. Band 2: Der Nordosten – Orderland, Barnim und Lebus. Forschungen und Beiträge des Brandenburgisches Landesdenkmalamtes und Archäologischen Landesmuseums. Worms: Wernersche Verlagsgesellschaft
Corbeil, M.C. (2015). Conservation institutions as agents of change. In: Studies in Conservation 2015 VOL. 60 SUPPLEMENT 2 “Conservation science“, pp. 2-32
Corr, S., Hutchings, J., van der Burg, J., Cueco, D. A., Noll-Minor, M., Ortlik, A. G., & Dobrusskin, S. (2011). Competences for Access to the Conservation-Restoration Profession. Brussels: E.C.C.O.
Council of Europe (Ed.). (2006). Council of Europe Framework Convention on the Value of Cultural Heritage for Society: Faro, 27. 10. 2005 = Convention-cadre du Conseil de l’Europe sur la valeur du patrimoine culturel pour la société. Strasbourg: Council of Europe Publications
E.C.C.O. (2001). Acteurs du Patrimoine Européen et Législation. Survey of the legal and professional responsibilities of the conservator-restorer in regard of the other parties involved in the preservation and conservation of cultural heritage. Rome: E.C.C.O
ICOMOS (2003): Principles for the Preservation and Conservation-Restoration of Wall Paintings, In: Petzet, M. (Ed.). International Principles of Preservation. ICOMOS Monuments and Sites XX, pp. 88-91. Berlin: Hendrik Bäßler Verlag
IOM - International Institute of Museums (1940). Manual on the conservation of paintings. International Institute of Intellectual Cooperation, URL: https://atom.archives.unesco.org/manuel-de-la-conservation-des-peintures
Hirsch Hadorn G., Hoffmann-Riem H., Biber-Klemm S., Grossenbacher-Mansuy W., Joye D., Pohl C., Wiesmann U. & Zemp E. (Eds.). (2008). Handbook of Transdisciplinary Research. Springer Netherlands
Laue, S., Bläuer, C. & Stadlbauer, E. (2008). Stand des Wissens und Forschungsdefizite. In: Salzschäden an Kulturgütern (pp. 59-65). Osnabrück: Deutsche Bundesstiftung Umwelt
Mittelstrass, J. (2003). Transdisziplinarität – wissenschaftliche Zukunft und institutionelle Wirklichkeit. Konstanz: UVK Universitäts-Verlag Konstanz
Nadolny, J. (2012), A history of early scientific examination and analysis of painting materials ca. 1780 to the mid-twentieth century, In: Stoner, J.H. & Rushfield, R. (Eds.). Conservation of Easel Paintings, (pp. 336-340). London: Taylor & Francis
Noll-Minor, M. (2005). The scene “Juda’s kiss” in the stage set Garden of the Passion theatre Holy Sepulchre of Neuzelle; In: Brandenburgisches Landesamt für Denkmalpflege und Archäologisches Landesmuseum (Ed.). Das Heilige Grab Neuzelle - Untersuchung und Konservierung der Szene „Judaskuss” im Bühnenbild „Garten”, (pp. 109-111). Petersberg: Michael Imhof Verlag
Noll-Minor, M. (2014). Conservator-restorers and other actors in building conservation – transdiciplinarity as a challenge, In: Grup tecnic (Ed.). La conservació arquitectònica, un treball en equip, (pp. 71-85). Barcelona: Conservadors-Restauradors Associats de Catalunya
Noll-Minor, M. (2017). Erforschen und Erhalten – transdisziplinäres Arbeiten in der Denkmalpflege. In: Verband der Restauratoren (Ed.). FORWARD- Forum wissenschaftliches Arbeiten in Restaurierung und Denkmalpflege. Eine Bestandsaufnahme zum Europäischen Kulturerbejahr 2018, (pp. 33-39). Bonn: Verband der Restauratoren
Rathgen, F. and Borrmann, R. (1916). Über Versuche mit Steinerhaltungsmitteln (IV. Mitteilung). In: Zeitschrift für Bauwesen 66, Heft 7/9, pp. 349–358
Segers-Glocke, C. (1994). Forschungsprojekt Wandmalerei-Schäden: ein Förderprojekt des Bundesministers für Forschung und Technologie. Schlußbericht zu den interdisziplinären Befunden. Arbeitshefte zur Denkmalpflege in Niedersachsen,11. Hameln: C W Niemeyer
Stoner, J.H. (2015). Vignettes of interdisciplinary technical art history investigation. In: CeROArt [Online], HS, Online since 10 April 2015, connection on 30 December 2018. URL: http://journals.openedition.org/ceroart/4508
Stout, G.L. (1949). Long-range conservation. In: The Museum News, Vol. 27 Nr.5, p. 7-8
Stout, G.L. (1950). The viewpoint of the conservator. In: Cercle des Alumni des Fondations Universitaires. Art et science. Alumni, 19, pp. 282-291
Sully, D. (2007). Colonising and Conservation. In: Sully, D. (Ed.). Decolonising Conservation: Caring for Maori meetinghouses outside New Zealand (pp. 27–43). Walnut Creek, CA, Left Coast Press
Töpler, W. (2005). Das Kloster Neuzelle und sein Heiliges Grab. In: Brandenburgisches Landesamt für Denkmalpflege und Archäologisches Landesmuseum (Ed.). Das Heilige Grab Neuzelle - Untersuchung und Konservierung der Szene „Judaskuss” im Bühnenbild „Garten”, (pp. 13-17). Petersberg: Michael Imhof Verlag
VDI (1987). VDI 3798 -Untersuchung und Behandlung von immissionsgeschädigten Werkstoffen, insbesondere bei kulturhistorischen Objekten. Verein Deutscher Ingenieure VDI. Düsseldorf: VDI Verlag GmbH
Venhorst, E.E. (2005). Kunsthistorische Betrachtungen zum Heiligen Grab aus der Stiftskirche St. Marien zu Neuzelle. In: Brandenburgisches Landesamt für Denkmalpflege und Archäologisches Landesmuseum (Ed.). Das Heilige Grab Neuzelle - Untersuchung und Konservierung der Szene „Judaskuss” im Bühnenbild „Garten” (pp. 18-27). Petersberg: Michael Imhof Verlag
Wong, L. (2000). Questionnaire Summary: Condition Recording in the Field of Wall Painting Conservation. In: GraDoc - Graphic Documentation Systems in Mural Painting Conservation (pp. 315-330). Rome: ICCROM
Wong, L. (2003). Documentation: Objectives, Levels and the Recording Process. In: Gowing, R. and Heritage, A. (Eds.). Conserving the Painted Past: Developing Approaches to Wall Painting Conservation, (pp. 46-54). London: James & James
Article Details
Abstract views: 477
Mechthild Noll-Minor, Brandenburg State Office for the Preservation of Historical Monuments
Chief Conservator of the Department of Conservation-restoration and Building Research in the Brandenburg State Office for the Preservation of Historical Monuments, member of ICOMOS and of the NSC Conservation-Restoration of Wall Paintings and Architectural Surfaces of ICOMOS Germany, member of the Board of the German Professional Association of Conservator-Restorers VDR Verband der Restauratoren
