Environmental Crimes of Early Romanian Communism: Focus on the Enemies of Agriculture
Alexandru-Ionuţ Petrişor
Doctoral School of Urban Planning, Ion Mincu University of Architecture and Urban Planning, Str. Academiei 18-20, Bucharest, Romania, 010014 (Romania)
Elena Tîrzman
Department of Managerial Assistance, Administrative Assistance and Applied Information Technology, Faculty of Letters, University of Bucharest, Str. Edgar Quinet 5-7, Bucharest, Romania, 010017 (Romania)
Abstract
The early beginning of the communist regime in Romania was influenced by transformations of agriculture (including husbandry and fishing), forced to develop intensively (replacing traditional technologies with mechanical ones) and extensively (by taking over natural systems, such as the wetlands). Since the yield did not increase as expected, the conflict with nature was aggravated by finding enemies among the species situated at the top of food chains, blamed for the losses. In order to expedite the outcomes of fighting against these species, media campaigns were developed in parallel with awards given to hunters and people who became part of the war. This paper attempts to correlate the environmental impact of campaigns against certain species with the loss of biodiversity based on statistical data. The analysis indicated that there were direct campaigns to eliminate species conflicting with economy and collateral victims. Each case study illustrates a different point; bustards were eliminated by carelessness (although protected, their status was not enforced); the pelican was eliminated due to insufficient knowledge and contrasting recommendations; and wolf was sentenced to death consciously. The results indicate that although many authors parallel nowadays communist and environmentalist policies, the real communist practices had a strong deleterious environmental impact despite a pro-environmentalist appearance.
Keywords:
pelican, wolf, bustard, vulture, extinction, degradation, agricultureReferences
ALMĂŞAN A., 1949, Menace of the wolf, in: Vânătorul, 1(13), p. 3.
Google Scholar
ALMĂŞAN A., 1950, The wolf destruction campaign, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 2(3), p. 3.
Google Scholar
ANDRONACHE I., 1954, Hunting as an economic, sportive and scientific factor, General Association of Sportive Hunters and Fishermen in Romania, Bucharest, Romania.
Google Scholar
ANONYMOUS, 1948, Kill the water birds, in: Foaia pescarului, 2, p. 6.
Google Scholar
ANONYMOUS, 1949, The pelican, in: Vânătorul, 1(11), p. 7-8.
Google Scholar
ANONYMOUS, 1951, 30 years of glorious fight for freedom, peace and socialism, in: Probleme agricole, 3(4-6), p. 1-5.
Google Scholar
ANONYMOUS, 1952, Bustards and ice, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 4(12), p. 5.
Google Scholar
ANONYMOUS, 1954a, Agenda of sportive hunter and fisherman, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 6(1.
Google Scholar
ANONYMOUS, 1954b., Contribution of hunters to increasing the amount of widely consumed products, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 6(11), p. 14-15.
Google Scholar
ANONYMOUS, 1954c, How I killed 161 wolves, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 6(12), p. 21-22.
Google Scholar
ANONYMOUS, 1955, Let’s intensify the action for combating the predators, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 7(6), p. 2.
Google Scholar
ANONYMOUS, 1957, 40 years from the Great Socialist Revolution of October, in: Probleme zootehnice şi veterinare, 11, p. 5-10.
Google Scholar
ANONYMOUS, 1959, 15 years since the liberation of the country, in: Probleme agricole, 11(8), p. 7-13.
Google Scholar
BARDAN A., 1951, Combating the wolves, in: Vânătorul, 3(10), p. 2.
Google Scholar
BENEDETTI L., 2015, Romanian hunting law threatens wild birds and violates the Birds Directive, BirdLife International, Cambridge, UK, http://www.birdlife.org/europe-and-central-asia /news/romanian-hunting-law-threatens-wild-birds-and-violates-birds-directive (06.08.2018).
Google Scholar
BENEDEK K., 2018, Aspects in Romanian Nature Conservation – A Review, in: Environmental Engineering and Management Journal, 17(1), p. 95-106.
Google Scholar
BERNSTEIN T. P., 2014, Mao, Chinese communism, and the USSR, in: Journal of Cold War Studies, 16(2), p. 108-127.
Google Scholar
BODEA M., 1957, Catching baby wolves at their burrow, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 10(4), p. 12-13.
Google Scholar
BOTEZAT E., LINŢIA D., 1942, The pelican faces the economic exploitation of the Delta, in: Carpaţii: Vânătoare. Pescuit. Chinologie, 10(1), p. 173-177.
Google Scholar
C. B., 1954, The bustards, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 6(4), p. 4-5.
Google Scholar
C. B., 1958, Combating wolves at their burrow, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 7(5), p. 9-10.
Google Scholar
CĂTUNEANU I. I., 1950a, Current aspects of the bird colonies from the Danube Delta, in: Vânătorul, 2(8), p. 7.
Google Scholar
CĂTUNEANU I. I., 1950b, Few data on fish-eating birds, in: Vânătorul, 2(7), p. 5-8.
Google Scholar
CENTRAL DIRECTORATE FOR STATISTICS, 1961, Development of People’s Republic of Romania’s Agriculture, Central Directorate for Statistics, Bucharest, Romania.
Google Scholar
COZMA I., 1959, The agriculture of People’s Republic of Romania on its ascending trend towards socialism, in: Revista internaţională pentru agricultură, 6, p. 14-25.
Google Scholar
DĂRĂMUŞ N. R., 2015, Killing the bear with a glance: the gaze of senator Tanczos, in: Kamikaze, 6(29), p. 7.
Google Scholar
DIMITRIE R., 1952a, Fish-eating birds and their combating, in: Vânătorul, 4(12), p. 12-13.
Google Scholar
DIMITRIE R., 1952b, Fish-eating birds from Romania and their combating, in: Vânătorul, 4(11), p. 12-13.
Google Scholar
DIMITRIE R., 1957, The pelican, a species that is getting lost, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 10(4) p. 12-13.
Google Scholar
EARNHART D., 1997, Enforcement of environmental protection laws under communism and democracy, in: The Journal of Law and Economics, 40(2), p. 377-402.
Google Scholar
FENEŞAN O., FRĂSIE D., LUCA I., ONICĂ P., ROMANOVICI A., VASCAN O., VASILIU C., 1958, Development of agriculture in People’s Republic of Romania, Editura Agro-Silvică de Stat, Bucharest, Romania.
Google Scholar
FILIP S., COCEAN P., 2012, Urban industrial brownfields: constraints and opportunities in Romania, in: Carpathian Journal of Earth and Environmental Sciences, 7(4), p. 165-174.
Google Scholar
GACHE C., 2013, Environmental ethic values through ecological education in one Romanian master degree program, in: Natura Montenegrina, 12(3-4), p. 1-8.
Google Scholar
GALAŢCHI N., 1954, Destruction of wolves at their burrow, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 1(13), p. 3.
Google Scholar
GARE A., 1993, Soviet environmentalism: The path not taken, in: Capitalism Nature Socialism, 4(4), p. 69-98.
Google Scholar
GAVRILEŢ I., 1957, Forestry and hunting personnel in the wolf combating action, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 10(1), p. 15.
Google Scholar
GENERAL ASSOCIATION OF SPORTIVE HUNTERS AND FISHERMEN IN ROMANIA, 1954, Destroying the wolves in their burrows during the spring and summer, General Association of Sportive Hunters and Fishermen in Romania, Bucharest, Romania.
Google Scholar
GENERAL ASSOCIATION OF SPORTIVE HUNTERS AND FISHERMEN IN ROMANIA, 1955, Destroy the predators, General Association of Sportive Hunters and Fishermen in Romania, Bucharest, Romania.
Google Scholar
GEORGESCU M., 1970, The bear and wolf in our Carpathians, General Association of Sportive Hunters and Fishermen in Romania, Bucharest, Romania.
Google Scholar
GHEORGHE D., 2010, Wolves and vultures from Romania, executed as ‘enemies of the people’, in: România liberă, 6082, p. 6.
Google Scholar
HESKETH T., ZHU W. X., 1997, From Mao to market reform, in: British Medical Journal, 314(7093), p. 1540-1542.
Google Scholar
HORTA O., 2010, The ethics of the ecology of fear against the nonspeciesist paradigm: a shift in the aims of intervention in nature, in: Between the Species, 13(10), p. 163-187.
Google Scholar
IACOBI R., 1956, Enemy of the hunting economy, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 9(1), p. 17, 19.
Google Scholar
IANOŞ I., PEPTENATU D., ZAMFIR D., 2009, Respect for environment and sustainable development, in: Carpathian Journal of Earth and Environmental Sciences, 4(1), p. 81-93.
Google Scholar
IANOŞ I., SÎRODOEV I., PASCARIU G., 2012, Land-use conflicts and environmental policies in two post-socialist urban agglomerations: Bucharest and Chişinău, in: Carpathian Journal of Earth and Environmental Sciences, 7(4), p. 125-136.
Google Scholar
IOJĂ I. C., ROZYLOWICZ L., PĂTROESCU M., NIŢĂ M. R., VÂNĂU G. O., 2011, Dog walkers’ vs. other park visitors’ perceptions: The importance of planning sustainable urban parks in Bucharest, Romania, in: Landscape and Urban Planning, 103(1), p. 74-82.
Google Scholar
IOTICI N., 1949, Let’s prepare for combating the wolves , in: Vânătorul, 13(1), p. 7-8.
Google Scholar
JONES K., 2010, From Big Bad Wolf to Ecological Hero: Canis Lupus and the Culture(s) of Nature in the American-Canadian West, in: American Review of Canadian Studies, 40(3), p. 338-350.
Google Scholar
JONES K., 2011, Writing the Wolf: Canine Tales and North American Environmental-Literary Tradition, in: Environment and History, 17(2), p. 201-228.
Google Scholar
KHABIBULLOV M., 1991, Crisis in Environmental Management of the Soviet Union, in: Environmental Management, 15(6), p. 749-763.
Google Scholar
LAMPTON D. M., 1972, Public health and politics in China’s past two decades, in: Health Services Reports, 87(10), p. 895-904.
Google Scholar
LASSWELL H. D., 1951, The Strategy of Soviet Propaganda, in: Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science, 24(2), p. 66-78.
Google Scholar
LAZĂR F., 1953, Destruction of wolves, a communitarian action, in: Vânătorul, 5(12), p. 3-4.
Google Scholar
LECOURT D., 1977, Proletarian science?, NLB, London, UK.
Google Scholar
LOFTIN R. W., 1984, The Morality of Hunting, in: Environmental Ethics, 6(3), p. 241-250.
Google Scholar
MANTEJFEL P. A, LARIN S. A., 1951, Wolves and their combating, Physical Culture and Sport Press, Bucharest, Romania.
Google Scholar
MARINESCU B., COMAN C., 2010, The ethics of animals testing, in: Romanian Journal of Bioethics, (8)3, p. 197-204.
Google Scholar
MAZURSKY K. R., 1991, Communism and the Environment, in: Forum for Applied Research and Public Policy, 5(4), p. 39-44.
Google Scholar
MELIAN I., TODERAŞ I., CIOCÎRLAN V., 2005, Birds – systematic, biology, ecology, State University of Moldova, Chişinău, Moldova.
Google Scholar
MITTELSTRA J., 2003, The impact of the new biology on ethics, in: Romanian Journal of Bioethics, 1(2), p. 1-8.
Google Scholar
MURGESCU C. (ed.), 1960, Problems of developing and consolidating the socialist agriculture, Academy of People’s Republic of Romania Press, Bucharest, Romania.
Google Scholar
NAWROTZKI R. J., 2012, The politics of environmental concern: A cross-national analysis, in: Organization & Environment, 25(3), p. 286-307.
Google Scholar
NICOLAE S., 1956, Combat the wolves in their burrow, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 9(5), p. 8.
Google Scholar
OSTERGREN D., JACQUES P., 2002, A Political Economy of Russian Nature Conservation Policy: Why Scientists have Taken a Back Seat, in: Global Environmental Politics, 2(4), p. 102-124.
Google Scholar
PEPPER D., 1985, Determinism, idealism and the politics of environmentalism – a view point, in: International Journal of Environmental Studies, 26(1-2), p. 11-19.
Google Scholar
PETRIŞOR A.-I, 2016, Brief critical analysis of concepts used for assessing the market value to ecosystem goods and services in urban and spatial plans, in: Journal of Urban and Landscape Planning, 1-2, p. 98-108.
Google Scholar
POJOGA I., 1959, Fish culture, State Agriculture and Forestry Press, Bucharest, Romania.
Google Scholar
POPESCU A., 1955a, Let’s continue the action for combating the wolves in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 9(9), p. 20.
Google Scholar
POPESCU A., 1959, Let’s destroy the wolves, greatest enemies of the game, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 7(2), p. 8.
Google Scholar
POPESCU E., 1955b, On hunting and agriculture, in: Almanahul vânătorului şi pescarului sportiv, 5, p. 86-88.
Google Scholar
RĂDULESCU I., 1966, Pelicans as predators and possible vectors of parasitic diseases to hatchery fishes, in: Buletinul Institutului de Cercetări Piscicole, 25(1), p. 75-78.
Google Scholar
RUDESCU L., 1955, Game and hunting in the Danube Delta, in: Almanahul vânătorului şi pescarului sportiv, 5, p. 152-158.
Google Scholar
SAVIŢCHI A., 1951, The wolf combating campaign, in: Vânătorul, 3(1), p. 8-10.
Google Scholar
SCHNELL E., 1948, Decrease of our stag populations, in: Calendar vînătoresc, eds. Witting O., Coresi, Romania, p. 26-31.
Google Scholar
SCOTT P., 1973, Species Extinction in Birds, in: Bird Study, 20, p. 93-102.
Google Scholar
SPRENGER J., 2015, An Ocean of Locusts – The Perception and Control of Insect Pests in Prussian Brandenburg (1700-1850), in: Environment and History, 21(4), p. 513-536.
Google Scholar
STANCA I., 1954, How much does a wolf cost?, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 6(1), p. 19.
Google Scholar
STANCA I., 1954, How much does a wolf cost?, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 6(1), p. 19.
Google Scholar
STOICA C., 1957, Decision on the action of destroying wolves from the territory of People’s Republic of Romania, in: Vânătorul şi pescarul sportiv, 10(10), p. 18.
Google Scholar
ŞUMULEANU B., 1958, Should we protect or destroy the pelican?, in: Buletinul Institutului de Cercetări Piscicole, 17(3), p. 55-58.
Google Scholar
TAYLOR P. W., 1981, The ethics of respect for nature, in: Environmental Ethics, 3(3), p. 197-218.
Google Scholar
TEODOREANU E., 2017, Searching for the lost time. A historical climatology sketch, Paideia, Bucharest, Romania.
Google Scholar
WATTS L. L., 2011, With Friends Like These. The Soviet Bloc’s Clandestine War against Romania, RAO Press, Bucharest, Romania.
Google Scholar
WATTS L. L., 2013, The First Shall Be Last. Romania and the End of the Cold War, RAO Press, Bucharest, Romania.
Google Scholar
WITTING O. 1948, Conspectus of the hunting economy, in: Calendar vînătoresc, ed. Witting O., Coresi, Braşov, Romania, p. 20-25.
Google Scholar
Authors
Alexandru-Ionuţ PetrişorDoctoral School of Urban Planning, Ion Mincu University of Architecture and Urban Planning, Str. Academiei 18-20, Bucharest, Romania, 010014 Romania
Authors
Elena TîrzmanDepartment of Managerial Assistance, Administrative Assistance and Applied Information Technology, Faculty of Letters, University of Bucharest, Str. Edgar Quinet 5-7, Bucharest, Romania, 010017 Romania
Statistics
Abstract views: 15PDF downloads: 6
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
