Comparative analysis of smart home management systems
Patryk Bąk
patryk.bak1@pollub.edu.plLublin University of Technology (Poland)
Grzegorz Kozieł
Lublin University of Technology (Poland)
Abstract
The article presents a comparative analysis of smart home management systems. The paper includes an analysis of the market, from which two systems were selected for detailed analysis. The choice was between the open source locally running Home Assistant system and the cloud-based Google Home solution. The detailed analysis includes a comparison of documentation, functionality, configurability, security, architecture and user feedback. In addition, two studies were conducted. The first addressed the response time of end devices to perform an action in the smart home management system. The second, on the other hand, addressed the time and number of steps required to configure devices with the systems.
Keywords:
Internet of Things, smart home, comparative analysis, management systemReferences
Poznaj swojego Asystenta Google, https://assistant.go-ogle.com/intl/ pl_pl/, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
Licencja oprogramowania Home Assistant, https://gith-ub.com/homeassistant/core/blob/dev/LICENS-E.md, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
Dokumentacja Alexa, https://developeramazon.com/, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
Documentacja IFTTT, https://ifttt.com/, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
A. Liu, I. Erol, W. Li, T. Yigitcanlar, Mapping two decades of smart home research, Technological Forecasting and Social Change 179 (2022) 121676-121700.
Google Scholar
M. Fisk, J. Malcolm, The implications of smart home technologies, Policy Press (2001) 101-124.
Google Scholar
D. Štreimikienė, V. Lekavičius, G. Stankūnienė, A. Pažėraitė, Renewable Energy Acceptance by Households, Sustainability 14 (2022) 8370-8387.
Google Scholar
H. Labiod, H. Afifi, C. De Santis, Wi-Fi, bluetooth, zigbee and wimax, Springer, Berlin, 2007.
Google Scholar
K. Chałubińska-Jentkiewicz, Rozwój nowoczesnych technologii w kontekście procesu stanowienia prawa na przykładzie strategii AI, Teka Komisji Prawniczej PAN Oddział w Lublinie 12.2 (2019) 53-71.
Google Scholar
A. Mohd, R. Muhammad, B. Mamun, R. Ibne, A review of smart homes past present and future, IEEE 42 (2012) 1190-1203.
Google Scholar
V. Lake, S. Madakam, Internet of Things (IoT), Journal of Computer and Communications 3 (2015) 164-173.
Google Scholar
J. Berg, WiFi overview, Linux wireless mini-summit, Berlin, 2009.
Google Scholar
BLUETOOTH, https://www.bluetooth.com/wp-content/-uploads/2019/03/Bluetooth_5-FINAL.pdf, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
What Is Zigbee and How Does It Work, https://www.makeuseof.com/what-is-zigbee/, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
I. Akyildiz, X. Wang, Wireless mesh networks, John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, 2009.
Google Scholar
What is ZigBee and compatible smart home devices, https://www.smarthome.news/news/other-systems/what-is-zigbee-and-compatible-smart-home-devices, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
What Is a Zigbee Smart Home Hub, https://robots.net/t-ech/what-is-a-zigbee-smart-home-hub/, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
The Matter Standard, https://bipartisanpolicy.org/blog/s-mart-homes-policy, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
What Is Matter? The New Smart Home Standard Explained, https://www.pcmag.com/how-to/matter-explained, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
Here’s What the ‘Matter’ Smart Home Standard Is All About. https://www.wired.com/story/what-is-matter, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
How safe are smart homes, https://usa.kaspersky.com/-resource-center/threats/how-safe-is-your-smart-home, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
J. Haney, S. Furman, Y. Acar, Smart Home Security and Privacy Mitigations: Consumer Perceptions, Practices, and challenges, Springer Proceedings 22 (2020) 393-411.
Google Scholar
Challenges, https://csrc.nist.gov/pubs/conference/2020/0-7/19/smart-home-security-and-privacy-mitigations/final, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
N. Guhr, O. Werth, P. Blacha, M. Breitner, Privacy concerns in the smart home context, SN Applied Sciences 2 (2020) 1-12.
Google Scholar
G. Ince, M. Kuyucu, S. Bahtiyar, Security and privacy in the smart home, 4th International Conference on Computer Science and Engineering, IEEE (2019) 113-118.
Google Scholar
The Future of Smart Homes. https://www.makeuse-of.com/smart-home-future-10-years/, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
The Future of Smart Homes, https://www.newsweek.com-/future-smart-homes-connected-complementary-conscious-1667957, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
The Future of Smart Homes: A Conversation with NXP Semiconductors, https://www.tomorrowsworldtoday.co-m/2023/09/04/the-future-of-smart-homes-a-conversation-with-nxp-semiconductors/, [23.10.2023].
Google Scholar
Dokumentacja Google Home, https://developers.hom-e.google.com/docs?hl=pl, [27.11.2023].
Google Scholar
Dokumentacja Home Assistant, https://www.home-assistant.io/docs/, [27.11.2023].
Google Scholar
Funkcjonalności Google Home, https://developers.hom-e.google.com/local-home/overview?hl=pl, [27.11.2023].
Google Scholar
Funkcjonalności Home Assistant, https://www.home-assistant.io/integrations/, [27.11.2023].
Google Scholar
Konfiguracja Google Home, https://developers.hom-e.google.com/matter/get-started?hl=pl, [27.11.2023].
Google Scholar
Konfiguracja Home Assistant, https://www.home-assistant.io/docs/configuration/, [27.11.2023].
Google Scholar
Bezpieczeństwo Google Home, https://developers.hom-e.google.com/docs?hl=pl, [27.11.2023].
Google Scholar
Bezpieczeństwo Home Assistant, https://www.home-assistant.io/docs/authentication/, [27.11.2023].
Google Scholar
Opinie o Google Home, https://play.google.com/store/-apps/details?id=com.google.android.apps.chromecast.app, [27.11. 2023].
Google Scholar
Opinie o Home Assistant, https://play.google.com/store/-apps/details?id=io.homeassistant.companion.android&hl=pl&gl=US&pli=1, [27.11.2023].
Google Scholar
Authors
Grzegorz KoziełLublin University of Technology Poland
Statistics
Abstract views: 22PDF downloads: 8
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
