Sustainable Urbanization Strategies: Mitigating Urban Heat Islands through Synergy between Economic Choices, Renewable Energy Consumption, and Environmental Interventions
Article Sidebar
Open full text
Main Article Content
DOI
Authors
Abstract
Amid the growing concern surrounding urban heat islands (UHIs) in the context of climate change, this study delves into the intricate interplay between economic factors and environmental elements and their impact on the intensity of urban heat islands across a panel of 13 countries during the period from 2000 to 2022. Using a panel fixed effect regression methodology, our investigation uncovers intriguing insights. Specifically, the study reveals that improving building energy efficiency and enhancing tree canopy coverage reduces urban heat island intensity (UHHI), demonstrating a negative correlation. Conversely, an increase in the green roof area, higher levels of renewable energy consumption, and greater investment in research and development exhibit positive associations with UHHI, signaling multifaceted dynamics. The panel Impulse Response Function offers a projection of short-term UHHI trends over the following decade. Significantly, variables such as the extent of green space, building energy efficiency, community resilience, renewable energy consumption, and research and development expenditures are expected to influence UHHI downward, underscoring the importance of sustainable practices and adaptability. Conversely, increases in the green roof area and tree canopy coverage are anticipated to positively impact UHHI, shedding light on the potential benefits of strategic urban greening initiatives. Furthermore, the variance decomposition analysis quantifies the proportional impact of individual variables on UHHI variance. Community resilience emerges as a pivotal factor, followed by the extent of green space, building energy efficiency, tree canopy coverage, and renewable energy consumption. By fostering energy efficiency, urban greenery, and resilience, cities can combat UHIs and cultivate sustainable urban environments that are resilient to escalating climate challenges.
Keywords:
References
1. AHAKWA I, 2023, The role of economic production, energy consumption, and trade openness in urbanization-environment nexus: a heterogeneous analysis on developing economies along the Belt and Road route, Environmental Science and Pollution Research 30(17), 49798–49816.
2. ALBUQUERQUE PAI A., ANAND A., PAZHOOTHUNDATHIL N., ASHOK L, 2023, Leadership perspectives on resilience capabilities for navigating disruption, Journal of Asia Business Studies, https://doi.org/10.1108/JABS-03-2023-0081.
3. ALMUSAED A., ALMSSAD A., ALASADI A., YITMEN I., AL-SAMARAEE S, 2023, Assessing the role and efficiency of thermal insulation by the ‘BIO-GREEN PANEL’ in enhancing sustainability in a built environment, Sustainabil-ity 15(13), 10418.
4. AL-SAYED M.M., ALANIZI A, 2023, Resilient cities to mitigate effects of climate change, in: IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1129(1), 012029.
5. BABA F.M., GE H., WANG L.L., ZMEUREANU R, 2022, Do high energy-efficient buildings increase overheating risk in cold climates? Causes and mitigation measures required under recent and future climates, Building and Environment 219, 109230.
6. BALA R. S., SATHYANARAYANAN S., JEYPARAKASH S. T., 2023, Understanding the relationship between Urban Heat Island and Urban Vegetation by reviewing three decades of satellite images for the Chennai Metropolitan Area, IOP Conference Series: Earth and Environmental Science 1210(1), 012029.
7. BANERJEE S., YIK S.K., DZYUBAN Y., CRANK P.J., YI R.P.X., CHOW W.T, 2022, Analysing impacts of urban morphological variables and density on outdoor microclimate for tropical cities: A review and a framework proposal for future research directions, Building and Environment 225, 109646.
8. BOUW K., TIGCHELAAR C., FAAIJ A, 2023, A new approach for modelling techno-economic performance of integrated energy systems on district scale for informed decision-making in a multi-stakeholder context, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Transition 3, 100045.
9. BYRNE J., TAMINIAU J., NYANGON J, 2022, American policy conflict in the hothouse: Exploring the politics of climate inaction and polycentric rebellion, Energy Research & Social Science 89, 102551.
10. CAGNO E., FRANZÒ S., STORONI E., TRIANNI A, 2022, A characterisation framework of energy services offered by energy service companies, Applied Energy 324, 119674.
11. CCKP, 2023, Maximum temperature, Climate Change Knowledge Portal, World Bank, Washington D.C., https://climateknowledgeportal.worldbank.org (19.08.2023).
12. CHANG Y., XIAO J., LI X., WENG Q, 2023, Monitoring diurnal dynamics of surface urban heat island for urban agglomerations using ECOSTRESS land surface temperature observations, Sustainable Cities and Society 98, 104833.
13. COLASANTE A., D’ADAMO I., MORONE P, 2022, What drives the solar energy transition? The effect of policies, incentives and behavior in a cross-country comparison, Energy Research & Social Science 85, 102405.
14. CORTESE T.T., ALMEIDA J.F., BATISTA G.Q., STOROPOLI J.E., LIU A., YIGITCANLAR T, 2022, Understanding sustainable energy in the context of smart cities: A PRISMA review, Energies 15(7), 2382.
15. CUONG V.H., KHAN W.A, 2023, Exploring the relationship between green spaces and mental health in urban environments, Journal of Sustainable Urban Futures 13(6), 22–33.
16. CUTORE E., VOLPE R., SGROI R., FICHERA A, 2023, Energy management and sustainability assessment of renewable energy communities: The Italian context, Energy Conversion and Management 278, 116713.
17. DALL-ORSOLETTA A., CUNHA J., ARAÚJO M., FERREIRA P, 2022, A systematic review of social innovation and community energy transitions, Energy Research & Social Science 88, 102625.
18. DANIEL R., CORTESÃO J., STEENEVELD G., STREMKE S., LENZHOLZER S., 2023, Performance of urban climate-responsive design interventions in combining climate adaptation and mitigation, Building and Environment 236, 110227.
19. DARWISH S., ALLEN R.R., LEMPKE M, 2023, Necessary complexity in the Anthropocene: new approaches in socio-ecological systems thinking, Do No Harm, and fragility integration, Development in Practice 33(5), 534–547.
20. DE MELLO L, 2023, Real estate in a post-pandemic world: How can policies make housing more environmentally sustainable and affordable?,Hacienda Pública Española / Review of Public Economics 244(1), 111–139.
21. DUTTA K., BASU D., AGRAWAL S, 2022, Evaluation of seasonal variability in magnitude of urban heat islands using local climate zone classification and surface albedo, International Journal of Environmental Science and Technology 19(9), 8677–8698.
22. EKMEKCIOĞLU Ö., 2023, On the identification of most appropriate green roof types for urbanized cities using multi-tier decision analysis: A case study of Istanbul, Turkey, Sustainable Cities and Society 96, 104707.
23. ELAOUZY Y., EL FADAR A., 2022, Energy, economic and environmental benefits of integrating passive design strategies into buildings: A review, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 167, 112828.
24. ELAVARASAN R.M., PUGAZHENDHI R., IRFAN M., MIHET-POPA L., KHAN I.A., CAMPANA P.E., 2022, State-of-the-art sustainable approaches for deeper decarbonization in Europe–An endowment to climate neutral vision, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 159, 112204.
25. ESTRADA-CARMONA N., SÁNCHEZ A.C., REMANS R., JONES S.K., 2022, Complex agricultural landscapes host more biodiversity than simple ones: A global meta-analysis, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 119(38), e2203385119.
26. FAHMY M., ELWY I., MAHMOUD S., 2022, Back from parcel planning to future heritage of urban courtyard: The 5th generation of Egyptian cities as a sustainable design manifesto for neo-arid neighbourhoods, Sustainable Cities and Society 87, 104155.
27. FIKRI M.A., SAMYKANO M., PANDEY A.K., KADIRGAMA K., KUMAR R.R., SELVARAJ J., SAIDUR R., 2022, Recent progresses and challenges in cooling techniques of concentrated photovoltaic thermal system: A review with special treatment on phase change materials (PCMs) based cooling, Solar Energy Materials and Solar Cells 241, 111739.
28. FLECK R., GILL R., PETTIT T.J., TORPY F.R., IRGA P.J., 2022, Bio-solar green roofs increase solar energy output: The sunny side of integrating sustainable technologies, Building and Environment 226, 109703.
29. GABOR A., REINWALD F., DAMYANOVIC D., 2023, Methodological Framework for Fostering the Implementation of Climate-Responsive Public Spaces and Streetscapes to Support Multifunctional Design, Sustainability 15(4), 3775, https://doi.org/10.3390/su15043775.
30. GAO Z., ZAITCHIK B.F., HOU Y., CHEN W., 2022, Toward park design optimization to mitigate the urban heat Island: Assessment of the cooling effect in five US cities, Sustainable Cities and Society 81, 103870.
31. GENOVESE P., ZOURE A., 2023, Architecture trends and challenges in sub-Saharan Africa’s construction industry: A theoretical guideline of a bioclimatic architecture evolution based on the multi-scale approach and circular economy, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 184, 113593.
32. GHOSH S., KUMAR D., KUMARI R., 2022, Assessing spatiotemporal dynamics of land surface temperature and satellite-derived indices for new town development and suburbanization planning, Urban Governance 2(1), 144–156.
33. GRAÇA M., CRUZ S., MONTEIRO A., NESET T., 2022, Designing urban green spaces for climate adaptation: A critical review of research outputs, Urban Climate 42, 101126.
34. GREENSTONE C., 2023, Digging up the Past: Re-Visiting the Potential Role Green Roofs can Play in Mitigating the Urban Heat Island (UHI) Effect: A Case Study of the Central Business District (CBD), Durban, South Africa, African Journal of Inter/Multidisciplinary Studies 5(1), 1–13.
35. HE B.J., WANG W., SHARIFI A., LIU X., 2023, Progress, knowledge gap and future directions of urban heat mitigation and adaptation research through a bibliometric review of history and evolution, Energy and Buildings 287, 112976.
36. HO J.Y., SHI Y., LAU K.K., NG E.Y., REN C., GOGGINS W.B., 2023, Urban heat island effect-related mortality under extreme heat and non-extreme heat scenarios: A 2010–2019 case study in Hong Kong, Science of The Total Environment 858, 159791.
37. HÜRLIMANN A.C., NIELSEN J., MOOSAVI S., BUSH J., WARREN-MYERS G., MARCH A., 2022, Climate change preparedness across sectors of the built environment–A review of literature, Environmental Science & Policy 128 277–289.
38. HUSSIEN A., JANNAT N., MUSHTAHA E., AL-SHAMMAA A., 2023, A holistic plan of flat roof to green-roof conversion: Towards a sustainable built environment, Ecological Engineering 190, 106925.
39. ISLAM M.M., IRFAN M., SHAHBAZ M., VO X.V., 2022, Renewable and non-renewable energy consumption in Bangladesh: The relative influencing profiles of economic factors, urbanization, physical infrastructure and institutional quality, Renewable Energy 184, 1130–1149.
40. JALALI Z., GHAFFARIANHOSEINI A., GHAFFARIANHOSEINI A., DONN M., ALMHAFDY A., WALKER C., BERARDI U., 2022, What we know and do not know about New Zealand’s urban microclimate: A critical review, Energy and Buildings, 112430.
41. KIM J.Y., PARK C.Y., HYUN J.H., KIM S.H., YUN S.H., LEE D.K., KIM J.Y., 2023, Landscape Design for Improved Thermal Environment: An Optimized Tree Arrangement Design for Climate-Responsive Outdoor Spaces in Residential Buildings Complexes, Sustainable Cities and Society 97, 104762.
42. LACHAPELLE J.A., KRAYENHOFF E.S., MIDDEL A., COSEO P., WARLAND J., 2023, Maximizing the pedestrian radiative cooling benefit per street tree, Landscape and Urban Planning 230, 104608.
43. LAIMON M., YUSAF T., MAI T., GOH S., ALREFAE W., 2022, A systems thinking approach to address sustainability challenges to the energy sector, International Journal of Thermofluids 15, 100161.
44. LAMPINEN J., GARCÍA-ANTÚNEZ O., LECHNER A.M., STAHL OLAFSSON A., GULSRUD N.M., RAY-MOND C.M., 2023, Mapping public support for urban green infrastructure policies across the biodiversity-climate-society nexus, Landscape and Urban Planning 239, 104856.
45. LEBROUHI B.E., DJOUPO J.J., LAMRANI B., BENABDELAZIZ K., KOUSKSOU T., 2022, Global hydrogen development – A technological and geopolitical overview, International Journal of Hydrogen Energy 47(11), 7016–7048.
46. LEHNERT M., PANEK J., KOPP J., GELETIC J., KVETONOVA V., JUREK M., 2023, Thermal comfort in urban areas on hot summer days and its improvement through participatory mapping: A case study of two Central European cities, Landscape and Urban Planning 233, 104713.
47. LEI Y., ZHOU H., LI Q., LIU Y., LI J., WANG C., 2023, Investigation and Evaluation of Insolation and Ventilation Conditions of Streetscapes of Traditional Settlements in Subtropical China, Buildings 13(7), 1611.
48. LEVESQUE A., OSORIO S., HERKEL S., PAHLE M., 2023, Rethinking the role of efficiency for the decarbonization of buildings is essential, Joule 7(6), 1087-1092.
49. LIU H., SKANDALOS N., BRASLINA L., KAPSALIS V., KARAMANIS D., 2023, Integrating Solar Energy and Nature-Based Solutions for Climate-Neutral Urban Environments, Solar 3(3), 382-415,https://doi.org/10.3390/solar3030022.
50. LIU S., YIN S., HUA J., REN C., 2023, Climate-responsive architectural and urban design strategies for adapting to extreme hot events, Adapting the Built Environment for Climate Change, 253-272.
51. LOCKE J., DSILVA J., ZARMUKHAMBETOVA S, 2023, Decarbonization Strategies in the UAE Built Environment: An Evidence-Based Analysis Using COP26 and COP27 Recommendations, Sustainability 15(15): 11603.
52. LOH N., BHIWAPURKAR P, 2022, Urban heat-mitigating building form and façade framework, Architectural Science Review 65(1), 57–71.
53. LUCCHI E., BAIANI S., ALTAMURA P, 2023, Design criteria for the integration of active solar technologies in the historic built environment: Taxonomy of international recommendations, Energy and Buildings 278, 112651.
54. MATSON P.A., STANKOV I., HASSMILLER LICH K., FLESSA S., LOWY J., THORNTON R.L., 2022, A systems framework depicting how complex neighborhood dynamics and contextual factors could impact the effectiveness of an alcohol outlet zoning policy, American Journal of Community Psychology 70(1–2), 18–32.
55. MCGREGOR A., COWDY M., 2023, Biourbanism | cities as nature: A resilience model for Anthromes, Science Talks 7, 100238.
56. MOOSAVI S., HURLIMANN A., NIELSEN J., BUSH J., WARREN-MYERS G., MARCH A., 2023, Transforming the agency and influence of landscape architects in climate change actions: An empirical analysis of barriers and facilitators, Landscape and Urban Planning 234, 104735.
57. MORALES-INZUNZA S., GONZÁLEZ-TREVIZO M.E., MARTÍNEZ-TORRES K.E., LUNA-LEÓN A., TAMAYO-PÉREZ U.J., FERNÁNDEZ-MELCHOR F., SANTAMOURIS M., 2023, On the potential of cool materials in the urban heat island context: Scalability challenges and technological setbacks towards building decarbonization, Energy and Buildings 296, 113330.
58. NWAILA G.T., FRIMMEL H.E., ZHANG S.E., BOURDEAU J.E., TOLMAY L.C., DURRHEIM R.J., GHORBANI Y., 2022, The minerals industry in the era of digital transition: An energy-efficient and environmentally conscious ap-proach, Resources Policy 78, 102851.
59. OKILJ U., ČVORO M., ČVORO S., ULJAREVIĆ Z., 2023, The Green Dimension of a Compact City: Temperature Changes in the Urban Area of Banja Luka, Buildings 13(8), 1947.
60. OQUENDO-DI COSOLA V., OLIVIERI F., RUIZ-GARCÍA L., 2022, A systematic review of the impact of green walls on urban comfort: Temperature reduction and noise attenuation, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 162, 112463.
61. OTAMENDI-IRIZAR I., GRIJALBA O., ARIAS A., PENNESE C., HERNÁNDEZ R., 2022, How can local energy communities promote sustainable development in European cities?,Energy Research & Social Science 84, 102363.
62. PARK C., LIM S., SHIN J., LEE C.Y., 2022, How much hydrogen should be supplied in the transportation market? Focusing on hydrogen fuel cell vehicle demand in South Korea, Technological Forecasting and Social Change 181, 121750.
63. PARSI S.S., LAL K.M., KOSBAB B.D., INGERSOLL E.D., SHIRVAN K., WHITTAKER A.S., 2022, Seismic isolation: A pathway to standardized advanced nuclear reactors, Nuclear Engineering and Design 387, 111445.
64. PENG Z., DEBNATH R., BARDHAN R., STEEMERS K., 2023, Machine learning-based evaluation of dynamic thermal-tempering performance and thermal diversity for 107 Cambridge courtyards, Sustainable Cities and Society 88, 104275.
65. PERERA A., HONG T., 2023, Vulnerability and resilience of urban energy ecosystems to extreme climate events: A systematic review and perspectives, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 173, 113038.
66. PLANAS-CARBONELL A., ANGUELOVSKI I., OSCILOWICZ E., PÉREZ-DEL-PULGAR C., SHOKRY G., 2023, From greening the climate-adaptive city to green climate gentrification? Civic perceptions of short-lived benefits and exclusionary protection, Urban Climate 48, 101295.
67. PRADES-GIL C., VIANA-FONS J.D., MASIP X., CAZORLA-MARÍN A., GÓMEZ-NAVARRO T., 2023, An agile heating and cooling energy demand model for residential buildings, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 175, 113166.
68. QIAO Z., LU Y., HE T., WU F., XU X., LIU L., HAN D., 2023, Spatial expansion paths of urban heat islands in Chinese cities: Analysis from a dynamic topological perspective, Resources, Conservation and Recycling 188, 106680.
69. RAJARAJESWARI C., ANBALAGAN C., 2023, Integration of the green and lean principles for more sustainable development: A case study, Materials Today: Proceedings.
70. RIEDMAN E., ROMAN L.A., PEARSALL H., MASLIN M., IFILL T., DENTICE D., 2022, Why don’t people plant trees? Uncovering barriers to participation in urban tree planting initiatives, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening 73, 127597.
71. PRADES-GIL C., VIANA-FONS J.D., MASIP X., CAZORLA-MARÍN A., GÓMEZ-NAVARRO T, 2023, An agile heating and cooling energy demand model for residential buildings. Case study in a mediterranean city residential sector, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 175, 113166.
72. QIAO Z., LU Y., HE T., WU F., XU X., LIU L., HAN D, 2023, Spatial expansion paths of urban heat islands in Chinese cities: Analysis from a dynamic topological perspective for the improvement of climate resilience, Resources, Conservation and Recycling 188, 106680.
73. RIEDMAN E., ROMAN L.A., PEARSALL H., MASLIN M., IFILL T., DENTICE D., 2022, Why don’t people plant trees? Uncovering barriers to participation in urban tree planting initiatives, Urban Forestry & Urban Greening 73, 127597.
74. ROBINEAU T., RODLER A., MORILLE B., RAMIER D., SAGE J., MUSY M., BERTHIER E, 2022, Coupling hydrological and microclimate models to simulate evapotranspiration from urban green areas and air temperature at the district scale, Urban Climate 44, 101179.
75. ROSALES PÉREZ N, 2023, Analysis of the extent to which resilience has been embedded into Mexico City planning, Economía, sociedad y territorio 23(71), 131–158.
76. SALMANIAN M., BAYAT A., 2023, Urban heat island: a primary guide for urban designers, Future Energy 2(4), 10–23.
77. SHARMA A.K., 2022, Synergies Between Traditional Urbanism and Climate Responsive Design, in: Traditional Urban-ism Response to Climate Change, Advances in 21st Century Human Settlements, Springer, Singapore, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-19-4089-7_5.
78. SHI Z., YANG J., ZHANG Y., XIAO X., XIA J.C., 2022, Urban ventilation corridors and spatiotemporal divergence patterns of urban heat island intensity: a local climate zone perspective, Environmental Science and Pollution Research 29(49), 74394–74406.
79. SINGH A.K., RAZA S.A., NAKONIECZNY J., SHAHZAD U., 2023, Role of financial inclusion, green innovation, and energy efficiency for environmental performance? Evidence from developed and emerging economies in the lens of sustainable development, Structural Change and Economic Dynamics 64, 213–224.
80. SOMMESE F., BADARNAH L., AUSIELLO G., 2022, A critical review of biomimetic building envelopes: Towards a bio-adaptive model from nature to architecture, Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews 169, 112850.
81. SONG Y., ZENG M., WANGX., SHI P., FEI M., ZHU J., 2023, Hierarchical Engineering of Sorption-Based Atmospheric Water Harvesters, Advanced Materials, 2209134.
82. TAN K., WANG J., 2023, Substrate modified with biochar improves the hydrothermal properties of green roofs, Environmental Research 216, 114405.
83. TAWFEEQ NAJAH F., FAKHRI KHALAF ABDULLAH S., AMEEN ABDULKAREEM T., 2023, Urban Land Use Changes: Effect of Green Urban Spaces Transformation on Urban Heat Islands in Baghdad, Alexandria Engineering Journal 66, 555–571.
84. WAN ROSELY W.I.H., VOULVOULIS N., 2023, Systems thinking for the sustainability transformation of urban water systems, Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology 53(11), 1127–1147.
85. WAN S., DING G., RUNESON G., LIU Y., 2022, Sustainable Buildings’ Energy-Efficient retrofitting: A study of large office buildings in Beijing, Sustainability 14(2), 1021.
86. WDI, 2022, World development indicators, World Bank, Washington D.C.
87. XU X., QIU W., LI W., HUANG D., LI X., YANG S., 2022, Comparing satellite image and GIS data classified local climate zones to assess urban heat island: A case study of Guangzhou, Frontiers in Environmental Science 10, 1029445.
88. ZHANG Y., SCHLUETER A., WAIBEL C., 2023, SolarGAN: Synthetic annual solar irradiance time series on urban building facades via Deep Generative Networks, Energy and AI 12, 100223.
89. ZHU S., YANG Y., YAN Y., CAUSONE F., JIN X., ZHOU X., SHI X., 2022, An evidence-based framework for designing urban green infrastructure morphology to reduce urban building energy use in a hot-humid climate, Building and Environment 219, 109181.
Article Details
Abstract views: 19