Socialist Realist Heritage in Poland – successes in protection and challenges for the future
Article Sidebar
Issue Vol. 25 (2026)
-
Twelve Years On: A Key ICOMOS France Event for the Dissemination of the Venice Charter’s Principles
Franca Malservisi1-13
-
A tough interrelation: Architectural conservation theory and electromechanical installations arrangement in late 19th and early 20th century monuments
Dimitrios Zygomalas15-31
-
The function of the inventory of monuments in the heritage protection system – the informative role or the legal form of protection?
Gabriela Gruszczak33-48
-
ICOMOS at 60. Surveying our Philosophical Foundations, and How They Might Be Fixed
Nigel Walter49-65
-
Socialist Realist Heritage in Poland – successes in protection and challenges for the future
Lukasz Mikolaj Sadowski, Aleksandra Sumorok67-83
-
Statement regarding the position of the Association of Art Historians (SHS), submitted to the conference entitled „Principles of the monument protection system – forms of protection, organisation of conservatory services, financing, and the role of stakeholders”, organised by the Polish National Committee of ICOMOS on 1–2 December 2025 in Warsaw
Malgorzata Gwiazdowska85-90
-
Access to cultural heritage and democratic participation
Cecilia Antonini Lanari91-103
-
Ship(s) of Theseus: Authenticiti(es) and Identiti(es) of Biñan's Alberto House(s)
Timothy Augustus Y. Ong, Drew Ashley Paige L. Rabadon105-123
Main Article Content
Authors
aleksandra.sumorok@asp.lodz.pl
Abstract
The debate on the protection of Socialist Realist heritage has been ongoing since the beginning of the twenty-first century. Initially, the greatest challenge was to develop appropriate criteria for assessment, to ensure effective protection, and to transform public awareness. With increasing temporal distance, attitudes toward Socialist Realism have evolved, particularly in the context of research and heritage evaluation. This shift has been reflected both within professional circles - among heritage conservators and art historians - and, eventually, within the broader public. As a result, the most significant buildings have been listed as monuments (although some spectacular demolitions have occurred), and their public perception has become more positive. Nevertheless, evaluation remains a major challenge, as it is often intuitive and imprecise - a problem already noted in earlier scholarship, together with the need to address new challenges arising from contemporary conditions [Szmygin,2012: 5].
Moreover, new issues and challenges concerning Socialist Realist heritage are emerging today. The dynamic transformations of modern cities make it necessary to open a new chapter in the discussion. We propose drawing attention to the problem of greenery - its maintenance and the inappropriate landscaping of squares and urban axes; the problem of parking lots (e.g., Constitution Square); the loss and degradation of architectural detail (retaining walls, coffered ceilings in arcades, sgraffito decorations); the disintegration of the urban fabric; insufficient cooperation between conservation services, municipal authorities, and urban greenery management.
Keywords:
Sustainable Development Goals (SDG)
- 11 - Sustainable cities and communities
References
Baraniewski, W. (1996). Ideologia w architekturze Warszawy realizmu socjalistycznego. Rocznik Historii Sztuki, 22, 236–238.
Bujalski, Sz. (2018). Apele nie pomogły. Lodz straciła jedną z unikatowych ozdób, https://lodz.wyborcza.pl/lodz/7,35136,23680421,styropianem-w-cenny-detal-lodz-straci-jedna-z-unikatowych-ozdob.html, accessed: 17.07.2018.
Clark, K. (2003). Socialist Realism and the Sacralizing of Space. In The Landscape of Stalinism. The Art and Ideology of Soviet Space, eds. E. Dobrenko, E. Naiman. Seattle.
Demshuk, A. (2016). Architecture Beyond Ideology: The Politics of Forgotten Landmarks in Communist East Germany. New York
Fitzpatrick, S. (1999). Everyday Stalinism: ordinary life in extraordinary times: Soviet Russia in the 1930s. Oxford.
Grześkowiak, R. (2024). Łodzianie o nowym Starym Rynku: Ładnie, ale wyraźniej widać to, co wokół woła o remont. https://lodz.wyborcza.pl/lodz/7,35136,30819720,na-starym-rynku-trwaja-prace-wykonczeniowe-lodzianie-ladnie.html, accessed: 24.03.2024.
Jankiewicz, A. (2015). Społeczne aspekty ochrony zabytków. Rola wspólnot, grup i jednostek w ochronie dziedzictwa kulturowego. In Zabytek Zadbany. Co to znaczy? ed. I. Liżewska. Warsaw.
Kałach, M. (2018). Ministerstwo kultury zapewnia, że odtworzy sgraffito z gmachu szkoły baletowej w Łodzi. Dekoracja ma ponad tysiąc obrońców. https://dzienniklodzki.pl/ministerstwo-kultury-zapewnia-ze-odtworzy-sgraffito-z-gmachu-szkoly-baletowej-w-lodzi-dekoracja-ma-ponad-tysiac-obroncow/ar/13369462, accessed: 27.07.2018.
Kenney, P. (1997). Building a People’s Poland: Workers and Communists, 1945–1950. Ihaca–New York–London.
Kępiński, K. (2023). Drzewa zamiast parkingu na pl. Konstytucji? https://www.architekturaibiznes.pl/drzewa-zamiast-parkingu-na-pl-konstytucji,27533.html, accessed: 14.01.2026.
Komorowski, W. (2017). Ochrona dziedzictwa urbanistyki i architektury Nowej Huty z lat 1949–1959 (Heritage conservation for urban planning and architecture of Nowa Huta of the years 1949–1959). Wiadomości konserwatorskie (Journal of Heritage Conservation), 49, 158.
Kowal, M. (2023). Łódzkie budynki ozdobione obrazami w technice sgraffito, https://lodz.tvp.pl/72014564/lodzkie-budynki-ozdobione-obrazami-w-technice-sgraffito-zdjecia, z dn. 2023.08.14, accessed: 15.01.2026.
Lewbow, K. (2013). Unfinished Utopia. Nowa Huta, Stalinism, and Polish society, 1949–56. Ithaca.
Lingenauber, K. (2020). Post-war Green Spaces – Recent Restoration and Upgrading Projects in Berlin. In A Future for Our Recent Past Model Projects of Modern Heritage Conservation in Europe, (80-81) eds. S. Brandt, J. Haspel, L. Kondrashev, A. Kudryavtsev, J. Ziesemer. Berlin.
MDM/KMA. (2011). Architektoniczna spuścizna socrealizmu. Warsaw- Berlin.
Murawski, M. (2015). Kompleks Pałacu. Społeczne życie stalinowskiego wieżowca w kapitalistycznej Warszawie. Warszawa.
Purchla, J. ed. (2011). Protecting and Safeguarding Cultural Heritage: Systems of Management of Cultural Heritage in the Visegrad Countries. Kraków.
Purchla, J.& Komar, Ż. (2011). Dissonat Heritage? The architecture of the Third Reich in Poland,.Cracow.
Sibila, L. E(d.) (2007). Muzeum Rozproszone Nowej Huty. Cracow.
Smolarczyk, M. (2019). Krakowski Greenway Wschód. Koncepcja systemu zieleni integrującego nowohuckie parki. Cracow Greenway East. The concept of a greenery system integrating the parks of Nowa Huta. https://repozytorium.biblos.pk.edu.pl/redo/resources/41551/file/suwFiles/SmolarczykM_KrakowskiGreenway.pdf
Stefański, K. (1982). Architektura polska 1949–1956. Kwartalnik Architektury i Urbanistyki 27, 13–104. Warsaw.
Sudjic, D. (2015). Kompleks gmachu. Architektura władzy (The Edifice Complex: The Architecture of Power). Warsaw.
Sumorok, A. & Załuski, T. (2017). Socrealizmy i modernizacje. Lodz.
Szlachetka, M. (2025). Uruchamia się żałoba, dostaję gęsiej skórki. Nie takie miały być efekty rewitalizacji w Łodzi. https://lodz.wyborcza.pl/lodz/7,35136,31799266,rewitalizacja-lodzi-kosztem-starych-drzew-pieknie-wygladaja.html, accessed: 26.03.2025.
Szmygin, B. (2012). Słowo wstępne. In Wartościowanie w ochronie i konserwacji zabytków, (Ed.) B. Szmygin. Warsaw-Lublin.
Szmygin, B. & Haspel, J. (2010 ). Zabytki drugiej połowy XX wieku - waloryzacja, ochrona, konserwacja. Warsaw-Berlin.
Tołwiński, T. (1937). Urbanistyka. Budowa miasta współczesnego. T. II. Warsaw.
Włodarczyk, W. (1991). Socrealizm: sztuka polska w latach 1950-1954. Warsaw.
Zaremba, M. (2012). Wielka trwoga: Polska 1944–1947: ludowa reakcja na kryzys. Warsaw.
Internet sources
https://lodz.wyborcza.pl/lodz/7,35136,31799266,rewitalizacja-lodzi-kosztem-starych-drzew-pieknie-wygladaja.html, accessed: 12.01.2026.
https://jedynka.polskieradio.pl/artykul/1259362,Gdyby-Gomu%C5%82ka-nie-zosta%C5%82-odsuni%C4%99ty-od-w%C5%82adzy-nie-mieliby%C5%9Bmy-maluch%C3%B3w, accessed: 12.01.2026.
Article Details
Abstract views: 9

