How young can a monument be? The normative premises of stating the "validity" of immovable monuments

Main Article Content

DOI

Marek Świdrak

hfh.icomos@gmail.com

https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3999-5124

Abstract

The aim of the article is to answer the problem of determining the nature of the legal requirement of temporal remoteness put upon potential Historic Monuments. Most of the papers that referred to the issue offered an understanding relying on determining stylistic/technical topicality of a property relying on the phrase „an evidence of a past period”, whereas some others suggested that there is no basis for expecting a temporal remoteness from a potential Historic Monument. Going beyond those commentaries this paper presents an analysis of the legal definition of Historic Monuments in conjuction with the definition of Contemporary Cultural Goods given in the Land-use Planning Act. A comparative analysis of those legal definitions leads to assuption that the legislator gave an alternative and more unequivocal basis for appraising whether a property is old enough to be listed on the Historic Monuments Register, which is to investigate whether the property is an achievement of a late generation.

Keywords:

Historic Monuments Register Listing Process, Minimum age of a Historic Monument, Polish Historic Monuments Preservation Act, Historic Monuments Officers’ practice in Poland, Contemporary Cultural Goods

References

Article Details

Świdrak, M. (2017). How young can a monument be? The normative premises of stating the "validity" of immovable monuments. Protection of Cultural Heritage, (3), 87–94. https://doi.org/10.24358/ODK_2017_03_06
Author Biography

Marek Świdrak, Jagiellonian University

absolwent historii sztuki, prawa i ochrony dóbr kultury na Uniwersytecie Jagiellońskim.
Doktorant historii sztuki na Wydziale Historycznym Uniwersytecie Jagiellońskim. Student
w Collegium Invisibile. Naukowo zajmuje się historią sztuki nowożytnej, głównie XVI i XVII w.,
w szczególności architekturą w Europie Środkowej, a także prawem ochrony zabytków.