Protection of places of memory as a theoretical and practical issue
Article Sidebar
Open full text
Issue No. 5 (2018)
-
Place of memory in the resource of cultural heritage of technology
Waldemar J. Affelt11-31
-
Memory places or areas of Memory
Marek Barański33-46
-
Sites of Memory - memory of the site, defining and rules of protection in Lodz planning documents
Maria Dankowska47-61
-
The First World War Monuments in East Prussia as a place of memory or a memorial areas
Joanna Jakutowicz63-74
-
Protection of places of memory as a theoretical and practical issue
Wojciech Kowalski75-89
-
Places of memory as a subject of theoretical reflection in heritage conservation
Janusz Krawczyk91-101
-
Polish Memorial Places - changes in interpretation and problems of protection in the 21st century
Jakub Lewicki103-113
-
Places of Memory in the Spanish Law
Anna Ławicka115-123
-
Artifacts in memorial places - the issue of restitution of museum ehxibits
Anna Mazur125-134
-
Ours or foreign? Cemeteries of the Great War in Lesser Poland. Threats and perspectives
Agnieszka Partridge135-144
-
The memory of a site. Role and Importance of Material Component in the Becoming of Sites of Memory
Grzegorz Rytel145-153
-
Memorial sites of the Ukrainian minority in the Podkarpacie Region vs. commemoration of the military conflict on the Poland-Ukraine borderland after World War II
Grażyna Stojak155-166
-
Sites of Memory - defining the concept with regard to heritage protection
Bogusław Szmygin167-175
-
Post-truth of inscriptions - dilemma of wall painting conservation
Ewa Święcka177-185
-
Memorial Plaque of Polish Senators
Jarosław Maciej Zawadzki187-190
Main Article Content
DOI
Authors
Abstract
As a result of analyse of chosen national and international legal acts author came to conclusion that no definition specifying places of memory as objects of legal protection had yet been adopted in these regulations. However this in no way means that places of memory remain completely outside legal area, although they are covered by the legal system of heritage protection merely within the framework of general definition of heritage. In particular, author argues that places of memory can be protected under 1972 UNESCO World Heritage Convention as definition of heritage (art. 1) encompasses „historical value” criterion in relation to all elements of this heritage, namely to monuments, groups of buildings and sites. Such thesis is strongly supported by practical application of criterion VI of Operational Guidelines by World Heritage Committee. Almost all monuments and sites inscribed on the World Heritage List under this criterion are to maintain memory of important events, beliefs, ideas etc. Intangible component was therefore a basis of these inscriptions although presence of material component as “a witness” was also important. It is however specially interesting to note that the Auschwitz Birkenau German Nazi Concentration Camp (1940-1945) was inscribed as the only one symbol of Holocaust what was underlined by the condition that no other such monuments would be inscribed in the future. It seems clear that by this fact the new principle of „symbolic representation” was adopted by Committee. The problem is that such principle has no legal basis, in particular it cannot be found in the 1972 Convention and for this reason decision establishing it is not binding for future inscriptions.
Keywords:
References
Adlercreutz T., Four issues of Cultural Heritage Law in six European countries. Central Board of National Antiquities. National Historical Museums, Sztokholm 1993.
Hunter M., The Preconditions of Preservation: A Historical Perspective [w:] Our past before us. Why do we save it? D. Loventhal, M. Binney (red.), Londyn 1981.
Kancelaria Sejmu – Biuro Informacyjne – BIULETYN, z posiedzenia: Komisji Kultury i Środków Przekazu (nr 15), Nr 204/V kad., 11.01.2006.
Kończyk L., Pedagogika (miejsc) pamięci, [w:] Ogrody Nauk i Sztuk, A. Kobylarek, A .Gil, L. Kołodziejczak, (red.), Debiuty 2012, Wrocław 2012.
Kowalski W., Kwalifikacja wartości zabytku w świetle prawa Stanów Zjednoczonych Ameryki Północnej. Ochrona dziedzictwa kulturowego, nr 2 (16) 2016. DOI: https://doi.org/10.24358/ODK_2016_02_07
Le Goff J., Nora P. (red.), Faire de l’histoire. Gallimard, Paryż 1974.
Miejsca pamięci na tle UNESCO 1972 World Heritage Convention oraz kryterium VI Wytycznych Operacyjnych jej stosowania. [w:] Ochrona Dziedzictwa Kulturowego, Nr 4, 2017.
National Register Criteria for Evaluation. Washington, D. C., U.S. Department of the Interior. www.nps.gov/nr/publictions/bulletins/nrb15/nrb152.htm.
Nora P., Kritzman L. D., Realms of memory: Traditions. Columbia Univ. Press, Nowy Jork, 1996.
Piotrowska K., Uzasadnienie wpisu na Listę Światowego Dziedzictwa w przeszłości i obecnie. [w:] Wyjątkowa uniwersalna wartość a monitoring dóbr światowego dziedzictwa, B. Szmygin (red.), Polski Komitet Narodowy ICOMOS i Narodowy Instytut Dziedzictw, Warszawa 2011.
Pruszyńskie J., Ochrona prawna zabytków w Republice Federalnej Niemiec. Teksty i komentarze, Warszawa 1992.
Szpociński A., Miejsca pamięci (lieux de memoire) [w:] Teksty Drugie, nr 4, 2008.
Tyler N., Ligibel T. J., Tyler I. R., Historic Preservation. New York, Londyn 2009.
Ustawa bawarska z 25 czerwca 1973 roku, Denkmalpflege Informationen. The Bavarian State Conservation Office. Protection and Preservation of Historic Buildings and Archeological Sites in Bavaria. Monachium 1987.
Values and Heritage Conservation. Research Report. The Getty Conservation Institute, Los Angeles 2000.
Watzke H. G., Cramer J., v. Kodolitsch P., Federal Republic of Germany [w:] Protection and cultural animation of monuments, sites, and historic towns in Europe. German Commission for UNESCO, Bonn 1980.
Zaborski M., Monuments and memorial sites in Poland and Germany [w:] Memory and Politics of Cultural Heritage in Poland and Germany, K. Ziemr (red), Warszawa 2015.
http://historicengland.org.uk/research/inclusive-hritage/the-slave-trade-and-abolition/sites-of-memory: Black British History in the 18th and 19th Centuries I Historic England (dostęp: 16.03.2018).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Register_of_Historic_Parks_and_Gardens_of_special_historic_interest_in_England (dostęp: 16.03.2018).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historic_England (dostęp: 16.03.2018).
https://historicengland.org.uk/listing/what-is-designation/registered-battlefields/ (dostęp: 16.03.2018).
Article Details
Wojciech Kowalski, University of Silesia in Katowice
absolwent Wydziału Prawa i Administracji Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego. Od 1975 roku związany z Uniwersytetem Śląskim, a następnie także z Politechniką Śląską w Gliwicach, gdzie jest profesorem zwyczajnym na Wydziale Organizacji i Zarządzania. Autor ponad 100 publikacji naukowych w języku polskim i językach obcych, wygłosił także wiele referatów i wykładów za granicą, w tym w Nowym Jorku, Paryżu, Edynburgu, Londynie, Wiedniu, Waszyngtonie, Oxfordzie, Hadze, Moskwie, Athens (Georgia, USA), Nashville, Heidelbergu, Santiago de Compostela i w Stambule. Jest członkiem ICOMOS, a w ramach polskiego Komitetu tej organizacji członkiem Sądu Koleżeńskiego, a także założycielem Committee on Legal, Administrative and Financial Issues (ICLAFI).
